Fifth Third’s $178m Tricolor hit - NDFI fears spread
- Fifth Third takes $178m Q3 charge-off tied to Tricolor
- JPMorgan reports separate $170m Tricolor hit
- Zions and Western Alliance disclose fraud-linked bad loans
- Investors shift focus to NDFI exposures and regional bank credit risk
- Fifth Third completes portfolio review and labels issue isolated fraud
- Nonbank lending is about 8 percent of Fifth Third’s book
- U.S. Bank flags immaterial First Brands exposure and higher provisions
- Truist notes under $200m First Brands exposure, fully reserved
- Executives stress strong underwriting, diversification and vigilance
Fifth Third logged a $178 million net charge-off in the third
quarter related to bankrupt subprime auto lender Tricolor, intensifying
scrutiny of regional banks’ exposure to non-depository financial institutions.
The Cincinnati lender joined a list of banks acknowledging
ties to Tricolor or to bankrupt auto-parts maker First Brands, after saying
last month it had uncovered alleged external fraudulent activity at a
commercial borrower that could result in an impairment of up to $200 million.
Other regionals, including Zions and Western Alliance,
disclosed bad loans linked to alleged fraud this week.
On Tuesday, JPMorgan Chase reported a separate $170 million
Tricolor charge-off, which CEO Jamie Dimon called “not our finest moment,”
adding, “When you see one cockroach, there are probably more.”
Those remarks crystallised market anxiety. “Investors are now
squarely focused on NDFI risks – and little else ever matters for banks when
credit questions emerge,” UBS analyst Nicholas Holowko wrote in a Friday note.
Fifth Third executives characterised Tricolor as an isolated,
fraud-driven event but said they completed an end-to-end review of their
asset-backed finance portfolio.
“We identified a couple of things that we’ll start to
implement from an enhancement standpoint, and we’ll continue to reinforce
ongoing monitoring in that space,” Chief Credit Officer Greg Schroeck said on
Friday’s earnings call.
Nonbank lending accounts for about 8 percent of Fifth Third’s
total portfolio, Schroeck said, adding the bank has been deliberate in keeping
its NDFI balances diversified.
CEO Tim Spence said Fifth Third has no relationship with
Cantor, which appeared in Western Alliance’s disclosure, and noted the bank
exited its relationship with First Brands “a handful of years ago” after issues
surfaced during collateral reviews.
Exposure to First Brands has surfaced elsewhere. At
Jefferies’ investor day, CEO Rich Handler said, regarding the situation, “We
believe we were defrauded,” according to the Financial Times.
U.S. Bank said on its third-quarter call that it has some
exposure to First Brands but described it as immaterial and already reserved.
In its wealth, corporate, commercial and institutional banking unit, provision
for credit losses rose about $103 million, primarily from higher reserves and
charge-offs on select problem assets.
CEO Gunjan Kedia said the bank does not expect to change
course, citing strong underwriting and appropriate reserving.
Truist executives reported less than $200 million of First
Brands exposure, fully reflected in loan-loss reserves.
CEO Bill Rogers called the recent problems “idiosyncratic and
uncorrelated events,” while emphasising that credit risk remains banks’ No. 1
risk and vigilance is elevated.