Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Magazine

Connect Magazine July Edition 2026 June 23, 2026

The Reason Risk Culture Fails Where Incentives Win

The Reason Risk Culture Fails Where Incentives Win

David Buck, Head of ERM

David Buck examines why many organizations struggle to embed effective risk culture despite significant investment in governance and oversight. He argues that incentives, behaviors, and decision-making processes have a greater influence on outcomes than p
  • Risk culture depends on behavior, not policy 
  • Incentives often drive unintended outcomes
  • Risk appetite must connect to decision-making 
  • Leadership actions influence culture significantly
  • AI may transform cultural monitoring     
     

    

Financial institutions may have spent years refining governance structures, risk frameworks, and oversight controls, but many organizations still struggle to embed risk culture into everyday decision-making where it matters most.

 

That is the view of David Buck, Head of Enterprise Risk Management at T. Rowe Price, who argues that risk culture only becomes effective when it moves beyond reporting exercises and becomes embedded in the operating rhythm of a business.

 

“The shift happens when risk stops being something you report on and starts being something you actually do,” Buck said. “The organizations that get this right integrate risk into their existing operating rhythm — their planning cycles, their business forums, their deal approvals — rather than only standing up separate risk committees that run in parallel to the business.”

 

Buck believes one of the strongest indicators of a healthy risk culture is when executives openly challenge assumptions and discuss uncertainty as part of routine decision-making rather than treating risk as a separate governance activity.

 

“When you hear senior executives ask ‘what are we trading off here?’ or ‘what could we be wrong about?’, it signals that uncertainty is a legitimate part of the conversation,” he said.

 

Drawing on behavioral economics, Buck argued that organizations should focus on designing processes that naturally encourage risk-aware decisions instead of relying solely on mandates or compliance structures.

 

“The concept of choice architecture suggests that if you design decision processes so that risk-aware choices are the default, you don’t have to mandate good behavior,” he said.

 

“You just make it easier.” Buck also warned that many institutions continue to struggle when translating board-level risk appetite statements into operationally meaningful metrics.

 

“The core discipline is cascading architecture,” he explained. “Taking enterprise-level appetite statements, focusing on the most impactful risks, and translating them into specific tolerances with defined thresholds, owners, and escalation triggers.”

 

However, Buck cautioned that firms frequently fall into the trap of excessive measurement, creating dashboards so overloaded with indicators that they generate a false sense of control.

 

“A dashboard with hundreds of metrics that no one acts on is arguably worse than no dashboard at all,” he said, “because it creates the illusion of oversight.”

 

According to Buck, organizations that are most effective at embedding risk appetite directly connect risk indicators to business planning and resource allocation decisions rather than treating them as governance exercises reviewed once a year.

 

He also stressed that policies alone are insufficient to influence behavior unless employees find them practical and relevant to daily work.

 

“What truly drives behavior is whether people find policies clear, relevant, and consequential in their day-today work,” Buck said.

 

That means firms must communicate risk expectations consistently through practical examples, narratives, and decision-making guidance rather than depending entirely on formal attestations.

 

Buck added that institutions should focus far more heavily on behavioral indicators such as escalation frequency, audit findings, and near miss reporting rather than simply measuring policy acknowledgments.

 

On incentives, Buck argued that many compensation structures unintentionally encourage behavior that conflicts with stated risk appetite because they reward outcomes rather than how those outcomes are achieved.

 

“If a business unit hits its revenue number by taking on concentrated exposure that violates risk appetite, the P&L still looks good,” he said.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.