Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Magazine

connect magazine issue 4 January 27, 2025

RCSA: The Changing Dynamics of Self-Policing Risk

RCSA: The Changing Dynamics of Self-Policing Risk

Penny Cagan, Head of Operational Risk, Americas, Columbia Center on Sustainable InvestmentLinkedIn profile for Penny Cagan

Risk Control and Self-Assessment (RCSA) has transformed from a periodic review to a dynamic, AI-enhanced process. As organizations align RCSA with strategy and adopt real-time monitoring, how can the framework evolve further to navigate future challenges?
  • RCSA has shifted from annual reviews to real-time processes, incorporating triggers and end-to-end accountability across business functions.

  • Integrating RCSA with strategic business processes enables organizations to identify vulnerabilities and streamline risk management.

  • Leveraging AI can enhance RCSA by automating monitoring, identifying trends, and analyzing control deficiencies more efficiently.

  • Combining scenario analysis with loss data transforms RCSA into a forward-looking tool, addressing both emerging and inherent risks.

display-middle-ads-here

RCSA – or Risk Control and Self-Assessment – has been around for a while now and is part of the accepted fabric of the risk function.

It’s a technique used almost universally since its introduction in 1987 – an innovation widely credited to Gulf Canada’s General Auditor at the time, Bruce McCuaig – and allows organizations including corporations, charities and government departments, to assess the effectiveness of their risk management and control processes.

But nearly 40 years on, technology and new thinking has reshaped the way we perceive, mitigate and manage risk.

Here we ask Penny Cagan, Senior Risk Adviser with PwC and a lecturer in Enterprise Risk Management at Columbia University in New York, to look at how the shifting sands of the risk landscape have impacted on the way we self-police our systems and processes.

How does the RCSA differ today from when you were first involved in it? 

RCSA has migrated for the most part from a once a year exercise to a more real time program, that is based on defining triggers.

For the most part, most institutions have created their baseline RCSAs, which means they have gone through at least one cycle for each of their assessment units.

Many organizations have moved to a process based approach and made connections with the processes in their organizations, such as linking the RCSA processes to the customer journey and the identified critical processes in the organization.

This approach allows for an end to end view of how risks and controls flow through the system, where they are vulnerable, such as the handoff points, and if controls are in fact being executed in the right stage of the operation. When a process approach is appointed, it allows for end to end accountability across a process that might cross functions.

It also allows the RCSA program to align more completely with strategy and business processes.

What was the most effective design and implementation of the RCSA? What made it special?

Years ago, when I was hired to restructure a RCSA program in a global bank, I introduced the concept of top down workshops with senior management.

At the time, I sensed a disconnect between a RCSA program that had become mostly a testing and ‘check the box’ exercise with what senior management most cared about.

I kicked off the redesigned RCSA program with workshops held with each of the direct reports to the CEO and their teams, and simply asked them what concerned them most. I then sat with their risk and control executives and mapped out a more bottom up approach that incorporated their concerns.

After that, I made sure there were touchpoints with these executives – and they were not easy to get hold of! – along the way, as RCSA was being executed.

I also changed the dialog with them so that we were discussing their concerns, rather than speaking ‘taxonomy talk’ – and don’t get me wrong, I love taxonomies and worked on one of the first ones in the industry. But it’s not how you talk to senior executives.

Ultimately, the most effective implementation of RCSA is one where it is used to manage the business, and is integrated into the overall operational risk or non-financial risk framework, such as New Business Assessments, Third Party Assessments, CCAR and quantification, governance, metrics, and issue management. 

How do you see the RCSA evolving in the future, possibly with the use of AI? 

Once the baseline is built, and an organization is mature enough to move to a trigger based approach, then the use of AI can add great benefit.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.