Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Magazine

Connect Magazine August Edition 2026 July 24, 2026

How Offshore Savings Can Become Costly Mistakes

How Offshore Savings Can Become Costly Mistakes

Jacquelyn Cayon, Vice President Global Supplier Services, JPMorganChase

Jacquelyn Cayon examines the risks organizations face when offshoring decisions are driven primarily by cost reduction. She argues that successful offshore strategies require a clear understanding of business objectives, operational dependencies, supplier
  •       Offshoring strategies should be driven by business objectives, not cost alone.
  •       Poor governance can undermine offshore effectiveness.
  •       Geopolitical developments are increasing outsourcing risks.
  •       Organizations are shifting from headcount-based to outcome-based models.
  •       Supplier expertise, training, and oversight remain critical to success.

Organizations that view offshoring primarily as a cost-cutting exercise risk creating bigger problems than the ones they are trying to solve, according to a senior vendor management executive who believes the most important question in any offshore strategy is a simple one: why?

 

Speaking during a discussion on offshore operations and vendor management, Jacquelyn Cayon, a sourcing, vendor management and oversight executive and expert with over 15 years of experience and currently serving as Vice President of Global Supplier Services for Loan Services at JPMorgan Chase, argued that organizations often become too focused on headline savings and fail to properly evaluate whether an offshore model is delivering meaningful business outcomes.

 

During the exchange at CeFPro’s Vendor Risk Dallas conference, Cayon said the rationale behind an offshore decision should determine everything from location selection and staffing models to oversight frameworks and long-term strategy.

 

“I think the biggest thing you have to consider if you’re going to offshore is the why,” she said. “You need to understand the why and what your goals are in relation to offshoring.”

 

Those objectives may include creating a 24-hour operating cycle, increasing flexibility, improving resilience, or generating efficiencies.

 

However, she cautioned that organizations frequently become fixated on projected savings without fully understanding whether those savings translate into improved performance.

 

“My biggest thing that I always work with my business partners with throughout offshoring is your why. What’s your goal?” she said. “I can make it look pretty on paper. I can make it look like you’re going to save money.”

 

For Cayon, offshoring should never become an alternative to automation or process improvement. She recalled one instance where a business partner suggested replacing an automated data feed with offshore personnel manually gathering and entering information.

 

“I would never replace an automated data feed, no matter the cost, with people augmentation,” she said. “That doesn’t make sense.”

 

While cost pressures remain an important driver, offshore strategies are becoming increasingly complicated by geopolitical developments and

economic uncertainty. According to Cayon, organizations must now evaluate not only the capabilities of suppliers but also their long-term sustainability.

 

“If you’re truly third-party outsourcing in an offshore, are they going to be able to maintain and stay through the new changes in the political environment?”

she asked.

 

Quality remains another significant challenge. Cayon described a case study involving an offshore operation where a seemingly straightforward process began generating unexpected results.

 

After conducting a detailed review, it emerged that the offshore team had abandoned the documented process and developed its own approach. “They had completely gone off process,” she said. “They decided to start doing it in a different way.”

 

The incident reinforced her belief that successful offshore arrangements depend heavily on experience, training, and partner selection. Organizations must determine whether a provider has genuine expertise in the activity being outsourced or whether they are effectively teaching the supplier how to perform the work from scratch.

 

Beyond process risk, Cayon highlighted a growing focus on productivity measurement. She believes many organizations are beginning to move away from offshore contracts based primarily on headcount and labour rates.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.