As regulators move away from highly prescriptive supervision, banks are being forced to take greater ownership of risk management priorities. Featuring insights from Darrin Benhart of KeyBank, the article explores how institutions are adapting governance
A quiet but consequential shift is reshaping how banks approach risk management, as regulators step back from prescriptive oversight and place greater responsibility on institutions
to define their own priorities.
According to Darrin Benhart, Chief Regulatory Officer at KeyBank, this transition is forcing banks to rethink long-standing
assumptions about governance,
accountability, and decision-making.
A key speaker at CeFPro’s
flagship Risk Americas conference earlier this month, Benhart reflected on an era when compliance frameworks were largely driven by external expectations rather than internal strategy, telling delegates: “Previously,
regulators often set a large portion of
the risk management organization’s priorities.”
That dynamic is now changing. Banks are being given more flexibility to determine their
own risk appetites and recalibrate frameworks with a stronger focus on innovation and efficiency.
This shift is particularly
evident in areas such as credit risk and anti money laundering, where banks are moving decision-making closer to the front line.
Rather than pushing issues upward to satisfy supervisory expectations, organizations are seeking to ensure that decisions are made at the appropriate
level within the business.
At the same time, examiners are changing their focus. “Examiners are getting much
more focused on the traditional
financial risk,” Benhart said, noting a
renewed attention on credit exposure,
private credit, and non-depository
financial institution risk.
This pivot reflects a broader
move back to fundamentals. While governance structures remain important, there is less
tolerance for what Benhart described as an overemphasis on documentation
at the expense of real risk
management.
Instead, regulators are
scrutinizing whether banks can demonstrate effective controls and
measurable outcomes.
The evolving supervisory
approach is also becoming more targeted. Large, resource intensive
reviews are giving way to shorter, more
focused examinations that concentrate on specific risk areas.
“You’re going to see much more
short term exams covering narrower
areas,” Benhart said, adding that banks may not always receive formal
feedback if no significant
issues are identified.
When feedback is provided, it
is increasingly framed as
observations rather than formal findings.
These observations highlight
potential gaps that do not rise to the level
of major regulatory action, giving banks
more discretion in how they respond.
“There will be a lot more
flexibility in the way bank management can address these items,” Benhart
said. However, this flexibility comes
with new challenges. Benhart
cautioned that regulators may be more
willing to cite violations of law in
situations where issues are identified,
even if they do not trigger broader
‘matter requiring attention’ or
enforcement.
Adding to the complexity is a growing divergence between regulatory agencies. While some bodies are moving quickly to
revise guidance and reduce
requirements, others have been slower to
follow, including a growing divergence
with international regulatory
expectations.