Regulatory Fragmentation Is Reshaping Balance Sheet Management
- Regulatory divergence across major jurisdictions is increasing complexity for treasury and balance sheet management functions.
- Separate reporting processes and fragmented data models are driving higher compliance costs and operational inefficiencies.
- Data standardisation and normalised data models can help banks reduce duplication and improve regulatory agility.
- Flexible, integrated treasury data frameworks are becoming critical for managing capital, liquidity, funding and risk requirements.
- Banks with strong data foundations will be better positioned to adapt to future regulatory change and maintain competitive advantage.
1. How is growing
regulatory fragmentation changing the balance sheet management landscape, and
what are the biggest implications for banks?
Treasury is in a peculiar place. Since the Global Financial Crisis (GFC), regulators have layered on rule after rule, and treasury now wears many hats: traditional treasury operations, balance sheet management, regulatory reporting and hedge accounting to name a few. All draw on the same balance sheet, yet most banks run them as separate processes with separate data. Fragmentation makes this worse. The same exposure can now attract different risk weights, transitional treatment and reporting depending on where it is booked, so capital, liquidity and funding decisions can no longer rest on a single set of assumptions.
The cost is large and poorly
understood. A November 2025 report published by The City- UK in association
with PwC put UK financial services
compliance costs above £33.9 billion a year, more than 13% of operating costs
on average. The indirect cost is worse. When systems, spreadsheets and teams
exist only to produce returns, a bank ends up with several versions of its own
balance sheet and a weaker grip on its true risk profile. Regulatory reporting
is standardised by design. It serves supervisors and policy makers. On its own it gives an individual bank
little. The value lies in the rules behind it, which set how much capital and
liquidity a bank must hold, and in the data beneath it. Reporting should be an
output of well-managed treasury data, not a function in its own right.
2. Where are you seeing
the most significant regulatory divergence between the UK, Europe and the US,
and how is it affecting strategic and competitive decisions?
The divergence is in direction, timing and design. The US is moving towards lower requirements. Under re-proposals published in March 2026, the agencies expect overall capital in the banking system to decrease modestly, with a separate approach for regional and smaller banks. Lower is not the same as simpler, though, since the proposals run to more than 1,500 pages.
Europe has taken a different route. Capital Requirements Regulation III (CRR3) has applied since 1 January 2025, with the exception of market risk. The EU output floor phases in at 55% this year, rising to 72.5% fully loaded. Targeted, time-limited changes to the market risk rules will apply for three years from 2027, justified on level-playing-field grounds.
The UK is implementing Basel 3.1 rather than CRR3. The Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) has committed to 1January 2027 for most changes, while the market risk internal model approach is deferred to 1January 2028. Full implementation of the transitional arrangements remains set for 1January 2030.
Interest rate risk shows the divergence at a smaller scale. In the UK it is still assessed through Pillar 2A, and the PRA's standard methodology does not assess Pillar 2A for basis risk, though it expects firms to set limits. I'm not convinced the recent clarifications on basis risk and FSA017 from the Bank of England’s interest rate gap report are well placed. Assuming all committed pipeline will be funded by new administered deposits will materially distort results.
The strategic effect is that the
same business now costs more to run in one jurisdiction than in another. The economics of mortgage, SME and specialist
lending depend on where a bank is regulated.
That shapes pricing, product appetite, where assets are held and who
banks end up competing with. A US bank can scale on lighter requirements, while
a UK or European bank absorbs more capital and complexity for the same balance
sheet.
3. How can banks build
a more holistic view of overlapping requirements and manage the cost of
compliance more effectively?
The answer is data standards and
normalisation. Most of the cost comes from banks maintaining separate
pipelines, classifications and spreadsheets for each regime, when the
underlying facts about the loan, the collateral and the counterparty are the
same. A normalised data model minimises duplication by holding each data point
local to the dimension it belongs to, so it can be reused. A single lending
record can then drive Risk Weighted Assets (RWAs), liquidity inflows, interest
rate risk sensitivity and internal analysis. Regulatory treatments sit on top
as calculation logic, and reports become outputs of that record rather than
separate projects.
Regulators are starting to say the same thing. The PRA's February 2026 discussion paper observes that its data collection spans more than 400 templates, with capital covered in around 120 and credit risk in over 100, and that similar underlying data is often cut or aggregated in different ways. Its stated aim is to collect data from firms "once and well", with data dictionaries supporting consistent definitions.
Banks have struggled to build this internally. Only 2 of 31 G-SIBs were assessed as fully compliant with BCBS 239 in the Basel Committee's latest assessment. The burden also falls hardest on smaller banks. A decade of US survey data shows the smallest banks spending roughly 11% to 15.5% of payroll on compliance, against 6% to 10% at the largest. For smaller banks whose core system data is often patchy, the priority is to capture a manageable set of attributes properly rather than model everything the regulation could theoretically require.
In our experience, this approach
can cut direct treasury costs by over 80%. Once the data is right, the same
foundation supports RWA optimisation, capital planning and what-if analysis as
well as reporting, so compliance spend starts producing management information.
It also frees teams from reconciliation to focus on managing risk. Imagine
that.
4. Do you expect
regulatory divergence between major jurisdictions to accelerate or eventually
give way to greater alignment? What should balance sheet managers be watching
most closely?
Unfortunately, I expect divergence
to increase, and that is concerning because it makes us less competitive. What
matters is that regulation delivers a sensible, standard set of rules that
guides banks and gives the regulator confidence without becoming a major cost
in itself. No jurisdiction has got this right yet.
Efforts to integrate data
submissions have struggled across the board. Europe looks the most advanced,
but the approach is very complicated and isn't delivering a competitive
advantage. The European Commission's July 2026 communication on banking competitiveness
is expected to lead to a legislative package in the first quarter of 2027, so
that is one to watch. Balance sheet managers should also follow the final US
rules and the UK's direction on interest rate risk.
The common thread is data.
Whichever way the rules move, the banks with well-structured data will adapt at
a fraction of the cost. They'll have new regulation working for them.
5. How might
fragmentation reshape competitive advantage across regions, and what should
banks do now to stay flexible, efficient and resilient?
Competitive advantage will go to
the banks that manage treasury data effectively. Those banks will see enormous
cost advantages, because they aren't paying to re-source, re-map and
re-reconcile the same data for every regime and every team. They will also have
a clearer view of their true risk position, which lets them focus on managing
risk and driving performance rather than on compliance mechanics.
Banks should act now on three
things. First, adopt a normalised data model with clear standards, so each data
point is captured once and reused everywhere. Second, treat regulatory
reporting as an output of that model rather than a stand-alone process. Third,
make regulatory logic configurable, so a rule change in any jurisdiction means
updating the calculation, not rebuilding the data.
Banks can't control how regulation
diverges, but they can control whether their data is ready for it.
CEO, ALMIS International
Luke Di Rollo is CEO of ALMIS International, leading strategy and product vision across Treasury, Risk, Regulatory Reporting and Finance solutions. With over a decade of experience working with banking institutions, he combines deep expertise in Treasury, Asset and Liability Management, Interest Rate Risk, Regulatory Reporting and Hedge Accounting with a technology-led approach to solving complex balance sheet management challenges. He holds a Masters in Accounting and Finance, is a Certified Bank ALM professional through UK ALMA, and has completed postgraduate study in Data Analytics at the London School of Economics.