Integrating Climate and Environmental Risk into Credit Provisioning
- BNP Paribas fully integrated climate risk into its IFRS 9 framework by year-end 2025.
- Climate overlays were removed following the completion of the bank's climate modelling framework.
- Data availability remains a key challenge for environmental risk modelling.
- Climate risk is currently assessed at client level, while geopolitical risk is evaluated more broadly at sector and geographic levels.
- Nature and biodiversity risk frameworks are expected to build upon existing climate risk methodologies.
- Environmental risks will become increasingly integrated into provisioning models over the coming years.
As financial institutions continue to evolve their approaches to climate risk management, integrating environmental considerations into credit risk and provisioning frameworks has become a key industry focus. Ahead of Climate Risk Europe 2026, Marc Irubetagoyena, Head of Modelling & Simulating at BNP Paribas, shares insights on climate risk integration within IFRS 9 models, challenges surrounding environmental data, and the future role of nature and biodiversity risk in financial institutions.
1. Many banks have identified climate risk as material, but relatively few have embedded it directly into expected credit loss calculations. Where does BNP Paribas currently draw the line between risks reflected quantitatively in provisioning models versus those managed through overlays, scenarios, and qualitative adjustments?
BNP Paribas identified both transition and
physical climate risk factors as material risks at an early stage within its
risk identification framework. Since year-end 2024, these factors have been
reflected within the bank's IFRS 9 framework through climate-related
adjustments to ratings and loss given default parameters, along with
forward-looking climate impacts incorporated into credit risk parameters.
While most material climate risk factors were directly modelled by year-end 2024, physical risk factors affecting the corporate asset class were initially addressed through an overlay approach. The full delivery of BNP Paribas' IFRS 9 climate modelling framework was completed by year-end 2025, allowing the cancellation of climate overlays and the full integration of climate factors into provisioning methodologies.
2. What has been the biggest practical challenge in incorporating environmental risk into provisioning, particularly around data quality, client transition plans, and the long time horizons over which climate impacts typically materialise?
The greatest challenge remains obtaining the
data required to support both climate-enhanced macroeconomic scenarios and
forward-looking impact models. This includes information such as client
emissions data, transition plans, building locations, and physical asset
characteristics.
Impact horizons are aligned with the
duration of the underlying credit portfolios, with a focus on modelling the
most material environmental risk factors across relevant timeframes. Ensuring
sufficient data quality and consistency remains central to developing reliable
climate-adjusted provisioning models.
3. We are seeing increasing geopolitical uncertainty affecting energy markets, supply chains, and transition pathways. How do you assess the interaction between geopolitical shocks and climate risk when determining credit risk assumptions and provisioning outcomes?
Climate and geopolitical risks often affect
similar transmission channels, particularly through energy markets, supply
chains, and broader economic activity. As a result, modelling methodologies can
share common features. However, much more detailed information is generally
available on climate-related matters than on geopolitical developments.
Within BNP Paribas, forward-looking geopolitical impacts are currently assessed at sectoral and geographic levels, while climate-related impacts are measured at client level. The interactions between climate and geopolitical risks are considered during scenario design, where macroeconomic analysis is expanded to incorporate both dimensions in a consistent manner.
4. As the industry starts to broaden its focus beyond climate, what do you see as the most promising approaches for incorporating nature- and biodiversity-related risks into credit risk frameworks, and what needs to happen before these can be reflected in provisioning methodologies?
The financial industry is increasingly
recognising nature and biodiversity as material sources of risk. However,
assessing these risks presents additional complexities, including limited data
availability, the localised nature of many environmental risk factors,
challenges in scenario design, and varying levels of awareness among clients
and financial institutions.
The most promising approach is to build on
the foundations already established for climate risk management. By
progressively expanding existing climate frameworks to include variables
related to water cycles, forests, wetlands, biodiversity, and the circular
economy, institutions can leverage existing data structures and scenario
methodologies. This approach could also accelerate integration with broader
risk management processes and resource allocation decisions.
5. Looking ahead three to five years, do you expect environmental risk to become fully integrated into core credit provisioning models, or will expert judgement and management overlays remain a significant component of how banks reflect these risks in financial reporting?
Over the next five years, environmental risk
factors are likely to become increasingly integrated into core credit
provisioning frameworks. Building upon established climate methodologies
provides a logical pathway for expanding the analysis to nature and
biodiversity risks.
Despite this progress, several barriers to full integration are expected to remain, particularly around data availability, risk quantification, and scenario development. Regular materiality assessments and enhancements to risk identification processes will therefore continue to play an important role. Developing approaches that translate localised environmental stresses into meaningful large-scale scenarios will be critical to advancing environmental risk management and financial reporting practices
Head of Modelling & Simulating, BNP Paribas
Marc is a member of the Group RISK Executive Board of BNP Paribas. In his current role, he is responsible for the global modelling and simulating platform of BNP Paribas, shared between RISK, Finance and ALM Treasury Group functions. After his studies of Engineering, Finance and Statistics, Marc started his career in consulting at Arthur Andersen in 1999. He joined BNP Paribas in 2002 within Group performance management. He drove the implementation of a value creation steering program and contributed to BNL Spa integration. In 2006, he moved to the Global Equity and Commodity business, launching notably a Private Equity offer. In 2009, he came back to Group Finance to coordinate the financial monitoring of the Retail Banking division, contributing to Fortis Bank integration. At the beginning of 2011, he launched a joint team between Group Finance and Group ALM Treasury to steer the liquidity of the Bank and implement a regulatory liquidity reporting framework. In 2015, he took the role of CFO of the Global Market business line. In 2017, he took in charge the stress testing framework for the Group.
LinkedIn profile