From Compliance Exercise to Strategic Decision-Making: The Evolving Role of Environmental Scenario Analysis
- Environmental scenario analysis should be integrated into strategy, risk management, and business planning rather than treated as a standalone compliance exercise.
- Supervisory focus is increasingly centred on the quality, use, and outcomes of scenario analysis.
- Proportionality, transparency, and continuous capability improvement are more important than methodological sophistication alone.
- Effective scenario analysis should drive tangible management actions and strategic decisions.
- Future frameworks are expected to expand beyond climate risk to capture interconnected environmental risks including biodiversity loss and ecosystem degradation.
Environmental
scenario analysis is becoming an increasingly important component of risk
management and strategic planning across financial institutions. As supervisory
expectations continue to evolve, firms are being challenged not only to conduct
environmental scenario analysis but also to demonstrate how the resulting
insights influence business decisions, risk appetite, and long-term resilience.
In this Q&A, Mira Lamriben discusses key supervisory priorities,
proportionality in methodology development, strategic integration, and the
future evolution of environmental scenario analysis.
1. As the EBA's expectations around environmental scenario analysis continue to evolve, what are the most common gaps you currently see in banks' approaches, and which areas are attracting the greatest supervisory attention?
One of the main messages from the EBA is
that environmental scenario analysis should not be treated as a standalone
modelling or compliance exercise. What matters is whether institutions are
developing a coherent forward-looking framework that connects environmental
risk drivers to their traditional risk categories, financial position and
ultimately their business model and strategy. We would therefore expect
supervisory attention increasingly to focus not simply on whether a bank has
performed a scenario analysis, but on its quality and its use.
Another important area is the distinction between stress testing and resilience analysis. Stress testing should help institutions understand shorter-term impacts on financial risks, capital and liquidity, while resilience analysis should take a longer-term perspective and challenge the sustainability of the institution’s business model and strategy under different environmental pathways. Ultimately, supervisors will increasingly be interested in the ‘so what?’ question: what has the institution learned from the analysis, and how has that insight changed risk management or strategic decisions.
2. Many institutions are still developing their climate risk modelling capabilities. How does the EBA expect firms to balance methodological sophistication with proportionality, particularly when data limitations remain significant?
The EBA expects proportionality rather than sophistication for its own sake. Data and methodologies are still evolving, so institutions can use proxies, qualitative analysis and expert judgement where necessary. What matters is transparency around limitations and a credible plan to progressively improve capabilities.
3. Beyond regulatory compliance, what evidence would demonstrate that environmental scenario analysis is genuinely influencing risk appetite, capital planning, lending strategies, and broader business decision-making?
The key question is: what changed because of
the analysis? We would expect mature institutions to be able to demonstrate a
clear chain from scenario results to management action. For example, material
vulnerabilities identified through scenario analysis could inform risk appetite
and limits, sectoral or geographic concentration limits, credit policies and
underwriting standards, pricing, collateral requirements, portfolio steering or
client engagement. So the test of maturity is whether we can trace a scenario
result through to a risk-management or strategic response.
4. Looking ahead over the next three to five years, how do you see environmental scenario analysis evolving from a risk assessment exercise into a core strategic planning tool for financial institutions?
Over the next three to five years, we would
expect environmental scenario analysis to move progressively from being a
relatively specialised risk-management exercise towards becoming part of
institutions’ normal strategic planning architecture.
Today, much of the focus is understandably
on building data, methodologies and governance. The next stage is greater
integration: connecting scenario analysis with ICAAP and ILAAP, risk appetite,
transition planning, budgeting, portfolio steering and strategic planning
rather than operating separate environmental-risk processes.
We should also expect scenario analysis to
become more dynamic. Instead of conducting an exercise periodically and
producing a static result, institutions should increasingly use scenarios to
test strategic choices: What happens to our portfolio under different
transition pathways? Where are concentrations emerging? Which clients or
sectors may require engagement? Where could new financing opportunities arise?
And how resilient is our business model if the transition occurs faster, slower
or differently than expected? This is particularly important because scenarios
are not forecasts. Their value lies in allowing institutions to explore
plausible alternative futures and understand vulnerabilities before those risks
crystallise.
5. As climate-related risks become increasingly interconnected with nature, biodiversity, and broader environmental challenges, how is the EBA thinking about expanding scenario analysis frameworks to capture these emerging dimensions?
Climate remains the most mature area, but
the direction of travel is clearly broader. Biodiversity loss, water stress,
pollution and ecosystem degradation can also translate into material financial
risks. While methodologies and data for these risks are still less developed
than for climate, institutions should progressively identify where such risks
are material and strengthen their analysis as capabilities evolve.
The EBA Guidelines on environmental scenario
analysis already encourage institutions to look beyond climate-related risks.
Going forward, an important focus will be on better capturing the
interconnections between climate and broader environmental risks, which can
reinforce and amplify existing financial risks, while maintaining a
proportionate approach as methodologies and data continue to mature.
Climate Risk Expert, EBA
Mira Lamriben is a Senior Policy Expert at the European Banking Authority (EBA), where she contributes to the development of the EBA's work on climate stress testing and environmental scenario analysis. Since joining the EBA in 2014, she has held a range of policy and economic roles across impact analysis, own funds regulation, and the Capital Markets Union team. Her experience includes the implementation of the Securitisation Regulation, the monitoring of issuances of own funds instruments by banks, tracking developments in the green bond market, and contributing to the EBA's policy work on ESG risks. Prior to joining the EBA, Mira was an Economist at the Banque de France. She holds a Master's degree in Public Affairs and Economics from Sciences Po Paris and a Master of Laws (LL.M.) from the University of Paris (La Sorbonne).