From Climate Risk to Climate Resilience: The Future of Sovereign Risk and Adaptation Finance
- Physical climate risk is becoming increasingly relevant within sovereign and corporate credit assessments.
- Important gaps remain in climate data, adaptation disclosure and risk measurement methodologies.
- Adaptation is increasingly viewed as a financial stability and risk management issue.
- Public-private partnerships play a key role in mobilising resilience and adaptation capital.
- Sovereign bond markets are likely to place greater emphasis on climate resilience and preparedness over time.
- Better disclosures, benchmarks and climate analytics will support more informed investment decisions.
- Financial innovation will be essential to expanding adaptation investment opportunities.
As climate-related disasters become
increasingly frequent and costly, physical climate risk is becoming a more
important consideration for investors, lenders and sovereign debt holders.
Ahead of Climate Risk Amsterdam, Dr. Arthur Krebbers discusses how climate
resilience is influencing sovereign credit assessments, the growing importance
of adaptation within financial decision-making, and the actions needed to build
a climate-resilient financial system.
1. We're seeing more frequent and costly
climate-related disasters globally. How are investors and lenders currently
incorporating physical climate risk into assessments of sovereign
creditworthiness, and where do you still see the biggest data or methodology
gaps?
Physical climate risk is becoming an
increasingly relevant component of sovereign and indeed corporate credit
assessments, reflecting its potential impact on economic growth, fiscal
balances, infrastructure resilience and debt-servicing capacity. Investors,
lenders and rating agencies are placing greater emphasis on climate
vulnerability, adaptation preparedness and the potential fiscal costs of future
climate events.
Improved geospatial data and climate
modelling have significantly enhanced risk assessment capabilities, yet
important gaps remain, including:
- Difficulty
determining which assets are most economically significant for the
sovereign and/or corporate.
- Challenges
quantifying indirect and cascading impacts across economies.
- Insufficient
disclosure on local adaptation measures and their effectiveness.
- In case of
corporates, limited visibility of critical supply-chain assets.
Also, while climate hazard exposure matters,
so does institutional capacity. Countries with stronger governance, fiscal
flexibility and adaptation planning are often better positioned to manage
similar climate risks.
2. To what extent has adaptation moved from
being viewed as an environmental issue to becoming a core financial stability
and risk management concern for banks, investors, and sovereign debt holders?
Adaptation is starting to move from being
viewed as an environmental issue to becoming a relevant financial stability and
risk management concern. As physical climate impacts become more evident,
investors are increasingly assessing exposure to climate risk and preparedness
for it. This is particularly relevant for long-dated, illiquid and lower rated
investments, where resilience can more clearly impact an investors return
picture.
However, measuring adaptation remains
challenging because of various factors:
- It can
difficult to isolate adaptation benefits and risks from broader economic
and geopolitical factors.
- Many adaptation
measures overlap with general infrastructure upgrades or operational
improvements, so defining adaptation investments at sovereign or corporate
level is not straightforward.
- Adaptation
strategic disclosures remain largely qualitative. In this regard, there is
no widely adopted adaptation benchmarking framework yet equivalent to TCFD
for climate risk disclosure.
Hence while adaptation is increasingly
influencing investment decisions, assessment methodologies are still evolving.
3. Many governments face increasing fiscal
pressures from climate damages while also needing to invest heavily in
resilience. What financing mechanisms or public-private partnerships are
proving most effective today in mobilising adaptation capital at scale?
The key challenge is identifying who
benefits from resilience investments and structuring financing accordingly.
Many adaptation and nature-based infrastructure projects generate broad
societal benefits, which is why governments and public-sector institutions
continue to play a central role.
Private capital becomes easier to mobilise
where there are clear and measurable economic benefits, such as:
- Compliance with
regulatory or building standards.
- Revenue
generation through carbon credits.
- Reduced
business interruption and operational losses.
- Lower insurance
costs.
- Increased asset
values and resilience.
In these cases, one can look to structure
financial instruments with clear private sector involvement and risk-sharing
mechanisms, i.e. crowding in private capital alongside public investment.
4. Looking ahead 10 to 15 years, do you expect
sovereign bond markets to meaningfully differentiate between countries based on
adaptation preparedness and climate resilience, and what signals would drive
that repricing?
Yes, although the process is likely to be
gradual rather than sudden. As climate data, disclosure standards and
adaptation benchmarks improve, sovereign bond markets will be able to
differentiate between countries based on resilience and preparedness, not just
climate exposure.
Key signals driving this repricing could
include:
- Greater
emphasis on adaptation within sovereign credit ratings, eg. upgrade and
downgrade drivers.
- Evidence
linking climate impacts to economic growth and fiscal performance.
- More
standardised sovereign climate disclosures.
Over time, a credible adaptation strategy
may become a minimum expectation for many institutional investors when
assessing climate-vulnerable sovereigns and indeed corporates.
5. If we fast-forward to 2040, what would a
climate-resilient financial system look like, and what actions should
governments, financial institutions, and investors be prioritising today to
make that vision a reality?
A climate-resilient financial system would
be one where adaptation is fully integrated into investment decisions, risk
management and capital allocation. Investors would be able to identify
resilience leaders and adaptation enablers with the same confidence that they
assess traditional financial metrics today.
This would require:
- Consistent and
decision-useful adaptation disclosures.
- Robust
benchmarks for resilience performance.
- Greater use of
geospatial data and (AI-supported) climate analytics.
- Better
measurement of adaptation outcomes and avoided losses.
What will then also help is continued
financial innovation to generate a broader array of adaptation investment
opportunities, to be able to support projects with differing risk and liquidity
characteristics.
The ultimate goal is to move adaptation from being viewed primarily as a risk-mitigation cost to being recognised as a source of long-term economic resilience, financial stability and investment opportunity.
Managing Director, Sustainable Finance Advisory, NatWest Markets N.V
Dr. Arthur Krebbers is Managing Director Sustainable Finance Advisory at NatWest. He has been supporting corporate and investor clients with their ESG strategies since 2014. Arthur’s areas of expertise include sustainable treasury and investment strategies, product development, rating management and stakeholder engagement. He is involved in numerous industry bodies that promote sustainability in the global capital markets. His research on sustainable finance is featured in a range of media outlets. Arthur has a PhD in Finance and is a Visiting Professor at Strathclyde University Business School.
LinkedIn profile