Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Articles

Article September 7, 2026

Resilience Plans Fail When Reality Changes the Scenario

Resilience Plans Fail When Reality Changes the Scenario

Financial institutions must treat operational resilience as a continuously evolving discipline rather than a periodic testing requirement. Risk practitioners argue that increasingly plausible cyber, third-party and technology disruptions demand progressive scenarios, clear executive accountability, credible workarounds and the ability to adapt rapidly when several responses must happen simultaneously.
  • Scenario testing should evolve as threats and business models change
  • Resilience must be embedded into transformation and organizational culture
  • Executive support is critical to effective resilience programs
  • Impact tolerances require continuous reassessment
  • Real disruptions demand multiple responses running simultaneously
  • Customer and regulatory communication must accompany operational recovery
  • Growing automation increases the importance of credible manual workarounds
  • Testing should expose weaknesses and drive investment priorities

Financial institutions should continually reassess whether their resilience scenarios still reflect the disruptions they are most likely to face, rather than repeatedly testing threats that have become less relevant.

Scenario programs should evolve alongside the business and external environment, with lessons feeding directly into investment, governance and transformation decisions.

Speaking at CeFPro’s 2026 Vendor Risk Europe event, the Head of Operational Resilience and Business Transformation at a bank said her organization had been forced to revisit the scenario-testing plan developed only a year earlier to determine whether it remained relevant.

New threats had made other scenarios more plausible, reinforcing the need for a continuous cycle of assessment, design, testing and learning.

The senior resilience executive argued that resilience should also be embedded directly into business transformation.

Every organizational change should prompt questions about whether it addresses vulnerabilities, improves processes or strengthens the institution’s ability to withstand disruption.

That approach requires organizational commitment rather than ownership by a specialist team.

A Business Transformation, Resilience and Oversight Officer at the same bank emphasized the importance of senior leadership engagement, arguing that executive backing is necessary to embed resilience throughout the business.

“Everything starts at the top essentially,” he said, stressing that leadership support helps resilience priorities penetrate the wider organization.

Impact tolerances must be equally dynamic. The resilience officer described them as the maximum disruption an organization can withstand before customers, reputation or financial integrity suffer unacceptable harm.

Those thresholds should be continuously reassessed as services and businesses evolve rather than established once and treated as permanent.

The practical difficulty was demonstrated through a scenario involving an outsourced instant-payments platform suffering a critical outage with an expected recovery window of four to eight hours.

Participants acting as an executive committee were given minutes to determine their response while customers, media and regulators were already becoming aware of the disruption.

The exercise exposed one of scenario testing’s most important lessons: real incidents rarely present organizations with a single neat decision.

Customer communication emerged as a priority because affected users needed reassurance that the institution understood and was managing the disruption.

But the scenario also required regulatory communication, activation of vendor plans and practical measures to maintain payment services.

One participant argued that the first priority was to “keep the show on the road,” using manual workarounds to restore some continuity immediately while other actions proceeded simultaneously.

The response plan should establish accountabilities, communications and vendor actions, with teams brought together into a war room where responsibilities are clearly understood.

The Head of Operational Resilience agreed that parallel action was critical. Regulators might know a widely used provider has suffered an outage without knowing which individual institutions depend upon it.

Banks therefore need to communicate proactively rather than assuming supervisory authorities already understand their exposure.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Sign up

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.