Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Articles

Article January 30, 2026

Why Automation Will Never Replace Judgment in Model Risk Management

Why Automation Will Never Replace Judgment in Model Risk Management

Chandrakant Maheshwari, First Vice President - Model Validation Lead, Flagstar Bank

Automation is reshaping model risk management, but it cannot replace human judgment. As models, regulations, and risks constantly evolve, overreliance on rigid tools can create new vulnerabilities. Effective MRM requires balance - using automation to supp
  • Automation in MRM offers efficiency but introduces new risks and rigidity
  • Models regulations and business priorities change too quickly for static tools
  • Human judgment remains essential for validation in volatile conditions
  • Documentation benefits from automation but requires continuous reassessment
  • Overly complex systems can reduce flexibility and adaptability
  • First line involvement is critical to realizing automation value
  • High risk models require judgment driven validation not calendar driven cycles
  • Systemic model risk cannot be managed through automation alone

In the world of model risk management (MRM), the word "automation" is often spoken with a sense of hope - and sometimes, misplaced expectation.

At every conference, vendors line up to present sleek solutions promising to revolutionize how we validate models, document processes, and manage reporting.

And while I fully appreciate the technological advances we are witnessing, I also recognize that automation is not a cure-all. If anything, it introduces a new set of challenges that we, as risk professionals, must navigate carefully.

One of the realities I have come to appreciate over years in MRM is that change is constant.

Models evolve, regulations shift, business priorities realign, and risk landscapes transform in ways we often cannot predict.

In this environment, the notion that a single tool - or even a suite of tools - can seamlessly automate large portions of our responsibilities is optimistic at best.

The more complex and "fancy" a tool becomes, the more inflexible it risks becoming. And in a function like MRM, where agility and judgment are critical, that rigidity can become a liability.

I’ve seen some remarkable technology showcased - particularly in areas like model monitoring and documentation.

There is clear value in automating aspects of data handling, standard testing, and tracking model performance over time. Yet, the heart of MRM is not just about ticking boxes or generating reports faster.

It’s about understanding risk in a dynamic environment, where interconnectedness between models - credit risk, fraud detection, liquidity management - can amplify vulnerabilities in ways that automation alone cannot anticipate.

One of the biggest misconceptions about automation in our space is that it can replace human oversight. The reality is far different. Yes, automation can and should handle repetitive tasks. But validation is not a static exercise.

Every model we review brings nuances shaped by current economic conditions, regulatory focus, and emerging risks.

For example, when geopolitical tensions rise or when markets shift unexpectedly, we cannot simply rerun last year’s validation script and call it complete. Each situation demands fresh judgment, contextual awareness, and a risk-based mindset that no algorithm can replicate.

Documentation is another area where automation offers promise but comes with caveats.

While tools can streamline the creation and maintenance of documents, the content itself is subject to continuous change - driven by evolving methodologies, regulatory interpretations, and business use cases.

What we document today may be insufficient tomorrow. Filling today’s gaps through automation only reveals new gaps as the environment shifts.

It’s an iterative process, and automation must be seen as a support mechanism, not a solution that eliminates complexity.

When we speak about investing in automation, I believe we need to ground those conversations in practicality. I often joke - but only half-seriously - that if Excel had just a few more advanced features, it would outperform many of the complex systems being sold to us.

There’s value in simplicity, especially when flexibility and adaptability are paramount. Tools should serve us, not trap us within rigid workflows that become obsolete the moment priorities change.

Another critical aspect often overlooked is the role of the first line of defense. MRM does not operate in isolation.

Any automation tool we implement will require collaboration and input from business units. If a tool only serves the second line, its value is inherently limited. This is why I always advocate for solutions that deliver benefits across the organization.

Tools that enhance efficiency for both the first line and MRM are far more likely to gain traction, justify investment, and deliver sustainable value.

The conversation around risk-based validation frequencies further illustrates the importance of judgment over automation. High-risk models, by their nature, demand frequent review - not because a calendar says so, but because the world changes rapidly.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Sign up

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.