Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Articles

Article September 1, 2026

US Bank Supervision Faces a Materiality Test

US Bank Supervision Faces a Materiality Test

US regulators are fundamentally reshaping bank supervision around material financial risks, promising greater clarity and fewer process-driven criticisms. Supporters see a more disciplined regulatory regime, while critics fear problems that initially appear minor could escape scrutiny until they threaten banks’ financial health.
  • OCC and FDIC are refocusing supervision around material financial risks
  • New rules establish formal standards for unsafe or unsound practices and MRAs
  • Regulators say the approach will reduce process-driven supervisory criticism
  • Banks have welcomed greater certainty and predictability
  • Critics fear higher thresholds could discourage early regulatory intervention
  • The legacy of SVB raises questions over when emerging vulnerabilities become material
  • Success will depend on identifying serious risks before financial damage occurs

US banking supervision is undergoing a significant philosophical shift as regulators move away from policing processes and documentation toward concentrating examiner attention on risks capable of materially damaging institutions.

The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency and Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. have finalized rules defining an “unsafe or unsound practice” and establishing new standards for matters requiring attention, or MRAs.

The reforms effectively introduce a materiality test governing when supervisory concerns warrant escalation.

Under the new framework, an unsafe or unsound practice must run contrary to generally accepted standards of prudent operation and either have materially harmed a bank or be likely, if continued, to materially damage its financial condition or create a material risk of loss to the Deposit Insurance Fund.

FDIC Chair Travis Hill said the reforms “shift the nature of supervisory criticisms” toward fundamental risks rather than the processes institutions use to manage them.

“In combination, the result is that examiners will focus only on issues that can have a material impact on the financial condition of an institution and on actual violations of relevant laws or regulations,” Hill said.

That does not mean supervisors must wait until damage occurs. Regulators can still intervene prospectively when current or reasonably foreseeable circumstances suggest material harm could result.

However, Hill has stressed that the prospect of damage must be “more than speculative or merely possible.”

The distinction could significantly change banks’ relationships with examiners. The FDIC has already closed or is closing a large majority of outstanding supervisory criticisms that fail to satisfy its revised standards, while converting many others that do into MRAs.

The OCC is pursuing a parallel overhaul. Its revised enforcement policies emphasize escalation, tailoring and corrective measures directly connected to identified deficiencies, while a separate proposal would distinguish substantive legal violations from technical ones.

Comptroller Jonathan Gould described the changes as a “return to risk-based supervision,” arguing that material financial risks and substantive breaches of law should take precedence over concerns involving policies, processes and documentation.

For banks, the attraction is predictability. American Bankers Association CEO Rob Nichols said the reforms would provide “needed certainty” while ensuring supervisory attention remained directed toward material financial risks.

But the change exposes a fundamental tension in prudential supervision: material problems rarely begin as material problems.

Critics fear that requiring a clearer connection between deficiencies and potential financial damage could discourage examiners from challenging weaknesses early enough to prevent them becoming dangerous.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Sign up

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.