Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Articles

Article September 23, 2025

UK banks face mounting pressure from FRTB uncertainty

UK banks face mounting pressure from FRTB uncertainty

As global divergence on FRTB and Basel 3.1 grows, UK banks face mounting uncertainty, rising costs, and strategic pressure in navigating reform.

  • UK caught between EU decisiveness on FRTB and US regulatory retreat creating uncertainty
  • Divergence in frameworks delays PRA action and complicates bank planning
  • Few banks adopt Internal Models Approach due to high costs low capital benefit and heavy operational burden
  • Preference for Standardised Approach risks systemic model risk and market herding
  • Diminished role of modelling challenges retention and motivation of quantitative talent
  • Dual reporting regimes add complexity and confuse strategic decision making
  • Supervisory focus shifting toward counterparty risk and shadow banking resilience
  • Failures like SVB highlight asset liability management weaknesses and regulatory blind spots
  • Potential adjustments to NMRF charges and PnL attribution may not drive IMA uptake
  • Risk of trading migration from UK if competitiveness declines

The implementation of the Fundamental Review of the Trading Book (FRTB) and the broader Basel 3.1 framework is proving to be one of the most complex and drawn-out regulatory transformations in recent memory.

According to the Head of Prudential Regulation at a leading UK bank, the United Kingdom now finds itself in a delicate position – wedged between the decisiveness of the European Central Bank and the uncertainty of the United States. 

“The fundamental dilemma for UK banks is the lack of clarity and synchronisation across global regulatory frameworks,” he told a recent CeFPro conference event.

On the continent, the European Union has set out a relatively coherent pathway for FRTB, though with limited uptake of the Internal Models Approach. 

The U.S., by contrast, has retreated from full implementation, with momentum slowed by political pressures and lobbying. 

This divergence, the expert explained, has left the UK Prudential Regulation Authority hesitant, delaying its own progress in cautious alignment with the U.S.

For banks, FRTB has become a case study in how the practical burdens of implementation often outweigh theoretical ambition. 

Years into the process, few firms have adopted the Internal Models Approach, discouraged by high costs, limited capital benefits due to output floors and heavy operational demands. Most have defaulted to the Standardised Approach. 

“The danger here is systemic model risk,” the senior executive said. “When everyone uses the same assumptions, distortions and herding behaviours are inevitable.”

The human cost is also underappreciated. Banks have poured resources into recruiting top quantitative talent, but the diminished role of internal modelling under Basel 3.1 risks demotivating these teams. 

Many firms are now running dual models – one for regulatory capital requirements, another for internal risk management. 

“This conflict creates complexity not only in systems and reporting but also in boardroom decision-making, where management must weigh competing metrics,” the executive warned.

Supervisory focus is also shifting. He pointed to the failures of large U.S. regional banks, including Silicon Valley Bank, as evidence of gaps in asset-liability management and weaknesses created by uneven regulatory perimeters. 

“The spotlight is moving from market risk to counterparty risk and shadow banking. Banks should be prepared to absorb more responsibility for monitoring and stress testing their less regulated counterparties,” he said.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Sign up

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.