Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Articles

Article September 19, 2025

The Art of Making Risk and Control Self-Assessments Meaningful

The Art of Making Risk and Control Self-Assessments Meaningful

Armel Massimina, Operational Risk Lead, National Bank of Kuwait (International)LinkedIn profile for Armel Massimina

A senior risk leader urges organisations to transform RCSAs into dynamic, insight-driven tools that enhance resilience and strategic alignment.

  • RCSAs must evolve from compliance to dynamic tools integrated into strategy
  • Controls need context awareness and performance testing for effectiveness
  • Success relies on leadership buy in clear roles strong capability and consistent methodology
  • Shift from annual static reviews to timely updates aligned with business changes
  • Clarify ownership link risks to objectives to drive engagement
  • Connect RCSAs to strategic risks and operational controls for coherence
  • Test critical controls proportionally with governance oversight
  • Annual attestations build accountability from frontline to board
  • KRIs must be meaningful tied to risk appetite with quantitative and qualitative insights
  • Effective RCSAs enhance operational resilience and disruption readiness
  • Technology helps but requires quality data and strong governance
  • Leadership orchestration ensures alignment and cohesion

Risk and Control Self-Assessments (RCSAs) are too frequently regarded as a compliance exercise, yet they have the potential to be much more. 

According to the Head of Operational Risk at an international bank, RCSAs should be dynamic, purposeful, and fundamentally linked to both strategic direction and governance.

Opening the discussion at a recent conference, the speaker recounted a personal story involving a near-miss carbon monoxide incident at home - where a detector had been installed but was positioned incorrectly, leading to an undetected emission which could have been fatal. 

The control was present, but ineffective. That is a lesson for business as well: controls only matter if they are effective and regularly tested, the expert noted.

“A control that exists only on paper is not enough; it must be proven in practice,” the expert stated, stressing that the frequency of testing should be in line with the criticality of the risk. 

Annual attestations by risk and control owners can further establish accountability within the business.

Successful RCSAs, the speaker emphasised, rest on three pillars: people, methodology, and tools. 

Without senior support, clear accountability, and suitable tools, any framework is likely to fail. It is essential to have people with adequate skills and knowledge to execute meaningful assessments.

The speaker noted that annual assessments may not be sufficient in today’s rapidly evolving risk environment. RCSAs must be dynamic and updated as the control landscape changes. 

They must be integrated into business decision-making processes and remain timely and relevant.

Fragmented responsibility across departments often weakens the effectiveness of RCSAs. 

The speaker argued that alignment with business objectives is essential: “When business units view RCSAs as enablers rather than obstacles, engagement and results both improve.”

RCSAs should also be connected to strategic risk and operational resilience, forming a clear line from board-level discussions down to daily operational controls. This linkage ensures a unified framework throughout the organisation.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Sign up

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.