Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Articles

Article November 4, 2025

Static Risk Appetite Frameworks Are Dead, Long Live Scenario Simulation

Static Risk Appetite Frameworks Are Dead, Long Live Scenario Simulation

Mark Norman, Head of Content, Center for Financial Professionals

This article explores new research from FIS and CeFPro showing that static, annual risk appetite frameworks are no longer fit for purpose. It outlines how financial institutions are adopting dynamic, integrated scenario simulation to align capital, liquid
  • FIS and CeFPro report finds static risk appetite frameworks are obsolete in today’s volatile landscape.
  • 48% of firms are revising frameworks; 86% are investing in scenario simulation.
  • Execution and integration now define success across capital, liquidity, and operational testing.
  • Stochastic modeling replaces deterministic methods to capture systemic interdependence.
  • Unified data and visualization drive board-ready, real-time decision-making.
  • FIS warns lagging institutions risk losing both prudential strength and competitive edge.

The latest report from balance sheet management technology providers FIS has revealed that static, annual risk-appetite frameworks are no longer viable in a world where volatility is the baseline and risks are tightly interconnected.

At the heart of the findings in the report, The State of Systemic Risk: How Financial Institutions are Reframing the Threat Landscape (September 2025), which FIS commissioned CeFPro to deliver, is execution.

Nearly half of institutions (48%) are actively reviewing and updating their Risk Appetite Statements, and another 18% are considering changes. In parallel, 62% are already investing in simulation and scenario analysis, while 24% are exploring solutions - meaning 86% recognize their current capabilities need to improve.

FIS – whose Balance Sheet Management platform integrates capital, liquidity and earnings modeling on modern cloud infrastructure – argues that this growth in awareness around execution marks a structural shift in which the broad approach is moving from regulatory box-ticking to strategic muscle.

When thinking about where to start, FIS identifies the biggest near-term gains in four tightly linked areas: risk-appetite visualization and monitoring (53%), capital planning (52%), liquidity and funding stress testing (50%), and measurement of operational and other non-financial risks (49%).

The close clustering underlines their interdependence - risk appetite defines boundaries, while capital and liquidity testing prove whether those limits hold under stress. FIS concludes that improving one without the others risks fragility in execution.

FIS also cautions that what it calls a ‘moderate instability’ mindset - the majority view among respondents - can blur urgency unless it is converted into concrete, testable scenarios.

In the report, FIS notes that banks need to move beyond a fire-drill mentality across ILAAP, recovery options and operational continuity, and embed it fully into the finance, risk and treasury operating model.

This, it says, could take the form of regular exercises, mapping triggers to actions, and rehearsing data, funding and operational workarounds before conditions deteriorate.

Technology and design choices also matter, according to the report, which found institutions are moving from deterministic models toward stochastic methods that generate ranges, percentiles and tail outcomes - better capturing the path-dependent nature of systemic shocks.

But, like all models, these are only as good as the data and the integration behind them – effectively the old ‘garbage in, garbage out’ rule.

FIS emphasizes unifying siloed sources and risk types, so correlations aren’t missed and ensuring scenario outputs are rendered in board-ready visuals that drive timely decisions.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Sign up

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.