Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Articles

Article February 25, 2025

Why I am Spending an Increasing Amount of Time as a CRO on Non-Financial Risk

Why I am Spending an Increasing Amount of Time as a CRO on Non-Financial Risk

didier magloire, self, Self

Non-financial risks (NFR) are becoming a more significant threat to financial institutions than financial risks. A CRO’s role is evolving, as these intangible threats, like climate risk, cyber threats, and reputation damage, require a culture-driven appro
  • Non-financial risks are increasingly occupying the focus of CROs, surpassing traditional financial risks in significance.
  • Traditional financial risk management approaches are insufficient for managing unpredictable non-financial risks, especially those impacting reputation and regulatory compliance.
  • Defining risk appetite for non-financial risks is a challenging task, as it often involves zero-tolerance thresholds for potentially damaging events.
  • A strong risk culture, built on communication, awareness, and accountability, is crucial in effectively managing non-financial risks and mitigating their impact on the organization.

display-middle-ads-here

In my capacity as a chief risk officer, I oversee a broad spectrum of risks which are largely divided into two pots. We call them financial and non-financial risk, a delineation which is commonly acknowledged in the banking industry.

Financial risks are the ones that first come to mind when I talk about finance and risk management in a social setting, like at a cocktail party where I might casually chat with another guest.

The guests understand credit risk and, with a little bit of explaining, market risk. But at this gathering, I rarely have the opportunity to delve deeper and explain how, as a CRO, I spend an increasingly large amount of my time on something incredibly interesting and intellectually challenging, which is non-financial risk (NFR).

If it does come up, I keep the explanation high level (and hopefully intriguing), saying a large part of my role is focused on people and corporate culture. Let me explain.

In banking, institutions are spending more money and time on managing compliance with regulations, reducing operational errors, fighting fraud and cyber threats. Add to that geopolitical uncertainties, climate risk and other external events, and the list of nonfinancial risks starts to become quite long.

Managing these risks is increasingly important because of the ever-changing external environment, the complexity of large banks, and regulators’ increasingly high expectations.

My argument is that despite its moniker, the impact of NFR on financial institutions is in many ways more threatening than that of financial risks.

NFR poses distinctive challenges, necessitating a departure from conventional financial risk management approaches that have been in place for decades. The problems NFR poses for CROs is that some NFR events are more difficult to predict.

Take climate risk as an example. The long term trend of more volatile weather events is very clear, yet the location and severity of the next big storm or drought can be hard to predict.

Reputation takes years to build, so protecting it is essential. The goal is to avoid the occurrence of any material events that might affect organizational reputation negatively. But the potential impact on the firm of any event is hard to quantify.

A bank’s reputation in the market or its relationship with regulators and media is precious, and damage to it can be immeasurable.

Consequently, it is difficult to apply the traditional financial risk management approach when addressing these risks.

Risk appetite’s battle with NFR

Typically, the risk management process starts with defining a risk appetite, and assessing the threshold within which a financial institution is willing to assume certain risks.

Financial risk is commonly expressed in monetary terms – typically representing the amount a bank is prepared to put at risk and potentially lose.

However, setting risk appetite for NFR is a much more elusive and theoretical concept. How do you set a risk appetite for an event when your stated tolerance should be zero occurrences?

Or how do you quantify damage to the firm’s reputation, for example being mentioned in a less-thanflattering story on the front page of The Financial Times?

A little bit is nice if the coverage is fair-minded, but not a lot if your institution or name is mentioned negatively.

That, however, does not sound very scientific. To mitigate this dilemma, we set key performance indicators, measuring the events that by themselves are manageable and measurable, but that may lead to bigger problems in the long run.

Key performance indicators may seem subjective or misguided. Keeping up with required training is an example. Does the training really help avoid major issues? In my view, it does – and if not enough people sign up to training by a certain time, I get an alert.

Therefore, it is crucial to regularly discuss these indicators, contextualise the concepts through real-life examples, such audit or self-assessment findings, study close calls or other bank mishaps, and so on.

These discussions represent the opportunity to emphasise the importance of individuals within the firm acting judiciously.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Sign up

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.