Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Articles

Article February 18, 2025

How a Scandal Sparked a Risk Management Transformation

How a Scandal Sparked a Risk Management Transformation

Craig Spielmann, Risk Intelligence Leader, Cross Country ConsultingLinkedIn profile for Craig Spielmann

A major trading scandal forced a global bank to rethink its approach to risk. What began as a compliance mandate evolved into a powerful risk management tool that transformed business strategy. This is the story of how RCSA went from a checkbox exercise t
  • A major trading scandal exposed critical weaknesses in internal controls, prompting a complete overhaul of risk management practices.
  • The initial compliance-driven approach to RCSA evolved into a strategic framework that enhanced decision-making and business resilience.
  • Innovative tools and methodologies, such as exposure-based assessments and automated risk evaluations, transformed how risks were identified and managed.
  • Aligning risk management with business objectives helped drive engagement, improve profitability, and strengthen overall control effectiveness.

My journey with Risk and Control Self-Assessment (RCSA) began in 1996 when I was tasked with creating and leading JP Morgan’s Information Technology Risk Management function. Just a week into the role, I attended a critical meeting prompted by JP Morgan’s involvement in the Sumitomo copper trading scandal, which revealed massive gaps in internal controls.

The directive was clear: implement an RCSA for every process across the organization. Armed with a simple template and a one-year deadline, my team and I embarked on the daunting task of educating staff, conducting over 200 sessions globally, and ensuring completion ahead of schedule. However, what began as a compliance exercise quickly evolved into a transformative initiative.

A New Approach to RCSA

Recognizing the potential to improve the process, we reimagined the methodology. Rather than asking teams to identify risks and controls themselves, we designed templates that required them to evaluate the state of their controls. We enlisted experts from various functions—disaster recovery, information security, HR, and audit—to define key risks and expected controls.

In the second year, we launched a system called Horizon, which simplified data capture and visualization for management. By incorporating algorithms to assess risk and control effectiveness, we provided a more realistic measurement of material risks. Horizon was a game-changer, quickly adopted across JP Morgan, and eventually commercialized in partnership with E&Y, reaching major banks, regulators, and government entities.

From Compliance to Strategic Value

Over time, RCSA matured into a strategic tool for risk management. By integrating loss event data and audit modules, we created a robust system for validating assessments. Moving beyond basic traffic light indicators, we shifted to exposure-based analysis, which provided actionable insights into potential losses and weak controls.

A particularly impactful implementation occurred at a forward-thinking bank whose CEO embraced a results-oriented approach. The process began by aligning RCSA goals with five business objectives:

  • Increasing market share
  • Enhancing profitability
  • Improving risk profiles
  • Expanding capacity
  • Selling underperforming units

By tying RCSA discussions to these goals, businesses engaged deeply, recognizing the connection to performance and bonuses. This alignment fostered a comprehensive assessment of processes, risks, and controls, supported by a common taxonomy and detailed business process maps.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Sign up

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.