Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Articles

Article September 24, 2026

Risk Culture Fails When Leaders Reward Silence

Risk Culture Fails When Leaders Reward Silence

Risk culture cannot be sustained through policies and training alone. Senior risk leaders argue that leadership behavior, psychological safety and effective second-line challenge are essential as commercial pressures, AI adoption and increasingly rapid reputational threats test whether corporate values genuinely influence decisions.
  • Risk culture depends on leadership behavior rather than written values alone
  • Employees must feel safe questioning decisions as risks become faster and more interconnected
  • Second-line risk and compliance functions should act as guardians of culture and challenge poor executive behavior 
  • Metrics can identify some conduct problems but cannot capture every damaging behavior
  • Commercial and AI pressures could increase tension between growth and effective risk culture
  • Reputation can collapse rapidly when markets lose confidence in culture and controls 

Risk culture becomes meaningless when employees learn that staying quiet is the easiest route to recognition and reward.

For financial institutions facing faster, increasingly interconnected risks, senior leaders must therefore demonstrate the behaviors written into corporate values rather than treating culture as something that can be established through policies, training programs or occasional management communications.

That was the central message from a discussion between a former chief risk and compliance officer at a global financial institution and the head of operational risk at the Nordic branch of a European bank.

The former risk executive argued that culture has always been fundamental to risk management because it represents “values as expressed through behavior.”

Formal frameworks and governance remain essential, but they cannot necessarily operate at the speed required by today's risk environment.

As risks become more complex, organizations instead need employees who are curious, prepared to question decisions and confident that senior management genuinely welcomes challenge.

Creating that environment begins with defining corporate values and the behaviors expected to support them. But the former executive warned that leadership cannot simply reinforce those principles periodically.

“It’s not enough for senior leadership to turn up to a town hall once a quarter and issue a reminder about the values,” he said.

Leaders must demonstrate them consistently and hold middle management accountable for propagating them throughout the organization.

The head of operational risk offered a Nordic perspective, where relatively flat organizational structures and strong levels of social trust can encourage employees to challenge management. But trust can also become a vulnerability if it creates an assumption that people and processes will inevitably operate as expected.

She described risk culture as the foundation supporting operational risk management, arguing that even imperfect processes can sometimes function because underlying organizational behavior compensates for their weaknesses.

That makes influencing behavior critical. Training remains important, but she cautioned against relying exclusively on digital learning. In-person meetings, storytelling and explaining why controls matter can make risk more tangible, while programs should be tailored to audiences ranging from junior employees to directors.

Collaboration with human resources is another important component because conduct, onboarding, training and employee behavior cannot easily be separated from risk management.

The second line also has a distinctive responsibility.

The former chief risk and compliance officer described risk and compliance functions as potential “guardians of risk culture” because they can independently observe behaviors that conventional metrics may miss.

Repeat audit findings and failure to complete mandatory training can provide useful indicators. But dashboards cannot easily capture a senior executive shutting down an uncomfortable discussion or discouraging challenge during a committee meeting.

“If you’re getting behaviors that’s shutting those things down, you can’t track that on a metric,” he said.

Second-line leaders must consequently be willing to challenge inappropriate executive behavior privately or through formal accountability mechanisms. Ultimately, poor conduct should influence performance assessment and potentially compensation.

That responsibility may become more difficult as commercial pressures increase.

The former executive argued that regulatory priorities have shifted somewhat from the intense focus on culture and conduct that followed the global financial crisis and subsequent LIBOR and foreign exchange scandals.

Growth, innovation and AI adoption are increasingly competing for management attention.

He pointed to the urgency surrounding AI, with senior executives fearing their commercial models could suffer if adoption moves too slowly. That can create pressure to tolerate risks in pursuit of competitive advantage.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Sign up

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.