Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Articles

Article July 25, 2025

Why Your ETF Isn't as Safe as You Think

Why Your ETF Isn't as Safe as You Think

Shameela Miah, Conference Producer

As markets exit a decade of stability, risk managers must adopt scenario-based strategies, stress-test liquidity, and embrace AI tools to stay ahead of today’s volatility-driven investment environment.
  • Risk managers must abandon outdated benchmarks and build models that reflect today’s volatility, interest rate shifts, and geopolitical instability.
  • ETF-heavy portfolios often give a false sense of diversification, as many smart beta or factor funds remain concentrated in the same underlying securities.
  • Liquidity assumptions are increasingly fragile, especially for ETFs built on illiquid assets, and stress testing must reflect simultaneous sell-offs across asset classes.
  • The adoption of AI tools and pre-modeled scenario baskets enables faster identification of emerging risks, but success also requires a cultural shift toward flexibility and forward-thinking action.

display-middle-ads-here

The golden age of benign markets is over – and risk managers who treat 2009 to 2022 as a reliable benchmark may be sleepwalking into disaster.

At CeFPro’s recent flagship Risk Americas conference in New York, a candid fireside chat exposed how outdated assumptions and overconfidence in exchange-traded funds (ETFs) could leave portfolios dangerously exposed.

With volatility, geopolitical shocks, and structural shifts now defining the landscape, resilience demands a radical rethink.

While the years between the financial crisis and 2022 were often treated as a baseline for risk modeling, the reality is that the extended period of near-zero interest rates and benign volatility was the outlier.

Today’s market presents a dramatically different reality. Investors must navigate a world where policy shifts, inflation concerns, and short-term market dislocations can drive meaningful drawdowns in days rather than months.

The need for a more dynamic and tactical approach to risk management has never been clearer.

A central theme that emerged was the imperative for scenario analysis to evolve. Traditional models based on a single base case and a few alternative outcomes are no longer enough.

Instead, risk professionals must prepare for a spectrum of divergent futures that are equally probable.

The path of inflation, interest rates, and geopolitical events can now drive entirely different regimes with vastly different implications for portfolio positioning.

The dominance of ETFs in portfolio construction was another focal point. Once lauded for their liquidity, transparency, and tax efficiency, ETFs are now raising important questions around hidden risks and the illusion of diversification.

Many portfolios that incorporate a variety of smart beta or factor ETFs – momentum, quality, and broad market indices – may unwittingly be concentrated in the same few names, particularly in the technology sector.

Without proper look-through capabilities to the underlying securities, investors can mistakenly believe they are diversified when in fact they are not.

A particularly pressing concern is the emergence of ETFs built on illiquid assets, such as collateralized loan obligations.

These instruments promise intraday liquidity but may not be able to deliver in times of market stress, posing systemic risks if investors attempt to exit simultaneously.

There was also a cautionary note about the proliferation of leveraged and single-name ETFs, especially those marketed to retail investors.

These vehicles are often poorly understood and can act more like lottery tickets than sound investments, compounding risk without a clear appreciation of underlying exposures.

In today’s environment, risk management requires granular transparency at the security level and a clear-eyed view of liquidity, so segmenting portfolios based on the true liquidity profile of their components is essential.

Equally important is acknowledging the potential breakdown of traditional correlations, such as the inverse relationship between equities and fixed income.

Stress testing must now account for environments where both asset classes sell off in tandem, undermining the foundation of many asset allocation models.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Sign up

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.