Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Articles

Article June 16, 2025

The Compliance Illusion: Why Third-Party Risk Management Needs a Reboot

The Compliance Illusion: Why Third-Party Risk Management Needs a Reboot

Mark Norman, Head of Content, Center for Financial Professionals

As regulatory pressures mount, Vendor Risk Europe revealed the disconnect between compliance and true operational resilience. DORA may be driving change, but financial institutions still grapple with siloed teams, outdated processes, and fragile vendor ov
  • Third-party risk is growing as reliance on external vendors increases
  • DORA highlights the gap between box-ticking compliance and real resilience
  • Fragmentation across IT, risk, and procurement hinders agility
  • Exit planning must shift from legal formality to service continuity strategy
  • Manual DORA reporting processes expose systemic inefficiencies
  • Testing of exit plans is rare, leaving institutions exposed
  • Continuous monitoring and vendor data freshness are critical
  • Risk must be embedded across all business units, not siloed
  • Automation and global data harmonisation are emerging priorities
  • Regulatory change is a catalyst, but culture change is essential

display-middle-ads-here

In the solutions-focused, always-on age of tech-simplified process and bite-sized information, it could be argued that third party risk management has adopted some of the characteristics of a corporate counterculture.

Just as technology promises simplification and one-stop shop solutions for customer-focused services like payments and account management, back office functions in financial organizations find themselves mired ever more deeply in increasingly complex and inter-connected regulatory and compliance frameworks.

Growing reliance upon external vendors for everything from cloud computing to customer service has expanded the scope and severity of risk dramatically.

Regulatory frameworks like DORA are pushing firms to go beyond static compliance and demonstrate active, real-time resilience. Yet many organizations still struggle with fragmented oversight, inconsistent data, and unclear accountability across risk, procurement, and IT.

Exit planning is often reactive, testing remains rare, business engagement is inconsistent. Modern risk managers are expected to battle not only an evolving threat landscape but also internal inertia and cultural resistance.

The endgame, it seems, is clear: a new operating model that integrates third-party oversight into strategic planning, embeds risk awareness across functions, and treats resilience as a continuous, dynamic process rather than a regulatory checkbox.

How to get there, however, is a different matter. 

Against that backdrop, then, this year’s Vendor Risk Europe event delivered a timely look at the practicalities, pitfalls, and possibilities of compliance and continuity in a fast-changing risk environment.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, the regulatory burden introduced by the Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA) took center stage, particularly on day one.

Natalie Druckmann, Head of EMEA at Certa, chaired the opening panel discussion, examining how institutions have fared since the first wave of DORA requirements went live across Europe last summer.

And despite broad agreement that the regulation’s intent is sound, the panelists were forthright about the implementation headaches it has caused.

What was largely accepted to be an implementation process that was painfully manual has spawned a litany of pain points: constantly shifting deadlines and challenges in aligning with IT functions were seen to hinder progress in other areas.

The DORA data templates were described by one panelist as “cumbersome”, who lamented the time lost to navigating overlapping frameworks from different regulators.

Another argued that institutions often confuse project delivery with actual resilience, cautioning that short-term compliance can mask long-term fragility. “Delivering 98 data points doesn't make your firm resilient,” he said. “It’s what happens next – embedding that into day-to-day operations – that matters.”

In fact, integration became a recurring theme, as it emerged that many firms still operate with siloed first and second lines, with responsibilities for operational resilience, third-party oversight, and IT often split across departments.

What quickly became clear in the event sessions was that fragmentation needs to end if institutions are to respond nimbly to disruption.

Nowhere was this more evident than in the oft-repeated assertion that financial organizations must move beyond seeing resilience as an IT or compliance issue and instead embed it across business units and decision-makers.

Another key focus was vendor exit planning, a topic given new life by DORA’s mandates and several high-profile vendor failures.

Two speakers in senior positions within global banks led the call to reframe exit planning from a reactive legal exercise to a proactive strategic imperative. Both stressed that exit plans need to be based on service continuity, not simply supplier relationships.

“In the past, we wrote exit plans like contracts – focused on individual vendors,” one noted. “But the real question is: what does the business need if this service fails tomorrow? That’s what the exit plan should be built around.”

His co-speaker agreed, highlighting the complexities of coordinating roles across legal, risk, IT, and business teams. “It’s like getting everyone to sign off on a group project that restarts the moment it finishes,” was her wry observation.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Sign up

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.