Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Articles

Article July 27, 2026

Regulation Without Accountability Threatens Banking's Future

Regulation Without Accountability Threatens Banking's Future

Ian Tyler, Senior Advisor, Financial Markets Consulting & ResourcingLinkedIn profile for Ian Tyler

Ian Tyler argues that effective regulation requires accountability, proportionality, and challenge. Drawing on decades of experience across treasury, capital management, consulting, and regulatory engagement, he examines how regulatory frameworks have evo

  • Ian Tyler argues that effective regulation requires accountability and challenge
  • Treasury and balance sheet management provide a holistic view of banking risk
  • Post-crisis reforms strengthened resilience but some measures may be overly restrictive
  • The UK’s approach to the countercyclical capital buffer differs from many major economies
  • Regulatory requirements should be more proportionate for smaller institutions
  • Greater parliamentary scrutiny and independent expertise are needed
  • Competition and growth should be considered alongside financial stability
  • Future regulation should balance resilience with proportionality

For Ian Tyler, the journey from risk practitioner to regulatory commentator has revealed both the strengths and weaknesses of modern banking supervision.

The Senior Advisor at Financial Markets Consulting & Resourcing has spent more than three decades working across treasury, balance sheet management, capital planning, consulting, and regulatory engagement.

That breadth of experience has given him a unique perspective on how regulation has evolved since the financial crisis and where he believes improvements are still needed.

Reflecting on his career, Tyler described treasury as the function that sits at the center of the bank, requiring practitioners to understand regulation, accounting, markets, products, capital, liquidity, and risk simultaneously.

“You have to understand the regulation. You have to understand the accounting. You have to understand markets because markets have limits,” he explained. The role also demands a detailed understanding of the institution itself and how risks interact across the balance sheet.

His experiences during the financial crisis shaped many of his current views. Having taken responsibility for capital management at Royal Bank of Scotland in early 2008, Tyler witnessed firsthand the pressures created by deteriorating market conditions, regulatory changes, and acquisition-related challenges.

Looking back, he highlighted how regulatory decisions sometimes amplified stress during periods of uncertainty. In particular, he pointed to examples where capital requirements increased just as institutions were already under pressure.

“The regulator communicated to the board that they wanted to move the goalposts,” he recalled, describing how higher capital expectations arrived precisely when market conditions were worsening.

Despite his support for most post-crisis reforms, Tyler believes some regulatory measures have become overly restrictive or insufficiently targeted.

He cited ring-fencing as an example of a policy that has imposed significant costs while delivering limited additional benefit. More broadly, he questioned whether certain regulatory frameworks adequately support competition and growth within the banking sector.

One area of concern is the UK's approach to the countercyclical capital buffer. Tyler argued that the original Basel intention was for the buffer to be deployed when economies showed signs of overheating.

Instead, he believes the UK has effectively embedded the buffer more permanently than many other major jurisdictions.

“We are an outlier,” he said, suggesting that the approach may unintentionally discourage lending and distort incentives.

He also questioned the application of minimum requirements for own funds and eligible liabilities to institutions that are not systemically important.

While Tyler strongly supports the principle of ending "too big to fail," he argued that some smaller institutions are being subjected to requirements designed for much larger organizations. This can create unnecessary costs and barriers to growth.

Underlying many of these concerns is a broader issue: accountability.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Sign up

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.