Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Articles

Article May 26, 2025

Why a New Regulatory Approach Leaves Europe's Banks Facing a Climate Reality Check

Why a New Regulatory Approach Leaves Europe's Banks Facing a Climate Reality Check

Thea Holland, Conference Producer

Supervisors across Europe are evolving climate stress testing from experimental pilots to strategic tools shaping financial resilience and policy.
  • Climate stress testing has evolved from awareness-raising exercises to structured supervisory frameworks
  • The EBA’s 2020 pilot established a baseline for assessing sustainability and climate-relevant exposures
  • Data limitations persist especially for SMEs retail exposures and physical risks with incomplete or proxy-based information
  • NGFS scenarios are now more refined capturing market transmission mechanisms like green bubbles and repricing shocks
  • Short-term testing focuses on vulnerabilities while long-term efforts explore strategic viability under different pathways
  • The Fit for 55 initiative is testing the financial system’s resilience under EU climate transition scenarios
  • Results from this cross-sectoral exercise will shape new supervisory guidelines under CRD6
  • Nature-related financial risks are acknowledged but remain a future priority due to lack of frameworks
  • Harmonized EU-wide guidance aims to integrate climate risks into prudential oversight
  • Supervisors are committed to realism and consistency while supporting the broader sustainability transition

display-middle-ads-here

A senior European banking executive has warned that a shift in regulatory mindset threatens to leave the financial sector playing catch-up in dealing with the challenges of climate risk. 

In a detailed address to climate risk professionals at CeFPro’s recent European Climate Stress Testing conference, a senior figure at the European Banking Authority (EBA) shared insights into the evolution, current state, and future direction of climate stress testing from a supervisory perspective.

As climate-related financial risks continue to gain prominence, the supervisory community has moved from early learning exercises to more structured frameworks that it hopes will ensure the banking sector is prepared for a low-carbon transition.

The early landscape of climate risk testing was defined by exploratory initiatives – top-down pilot exercises launched by central banks and regulators across Europe.

These efforts include notable projects by De Nederlandsche Bank (DNB), the European Systemic Risk Board (ESRB), and the European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA) and were intended primarily to raise awareness, test data availability, and develop preliminary methodologies.

None of these exercises, however, were intended to influence capital requirements.

Even the 2022 bottom-up exercise led by the European Central Bank’s Single Supervisory Mechanism (SSM) served a qualitative purpose, offering banks guidance and benchmark methodologies while steering them through a rapidly evolving risk landscape.

One significant milestone came with the EBA’s 2020 pilot exercise. This effort sought to classify the sustainability of banks’ exposures using available climate data, focusing on non-SME corporate exposures where emissions data was more accessible.

The analysis revealed that approximately 55% of such exposures could be considered climate-relevant, with 42% showing high greenhouse gas emissions intensity.

The pilot established a much-needed baseline from which more sophisticated analyses could evolve.

Despite this progress, several limitations remain. Climate data, particularly for SMEs and retail exposures, is still incomplete, often reliant on proxies or sectoral averages.

Scope 3 emissions are inconsistently estimated, and physical risk data lacks granular detail, often missing precise asset location details, all of which affects both comparability and the robustness of stress test outcomes.

Nonetheless, ongoing regulatory developments, including the EU’s Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation and the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD), are expected to significantly improve data availability in the coming years.

Scenario design remains a foundational component of climate stress testing.

The Network for Greening the Financial System (NGFS) has made substantial progress in refining its scenario framework.

Emerging concepts such as the ‘green bubble’ and sudden market repricing of climate risks highlight the urgency of capturing financial market transmission mechanisms in scenario design.

Looking ahead, there is a growing consensus on the need to integrate climate stress testing into regular supervisory assessments. However, such integration must strike a careful balance.

In the short term, testing should aim to assess banks’ vulnerabilities to near-term transition and market risks, relying on improved NGFS scenarios.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Sign up

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.