Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Articles

Article December 16, 2025

Short-Term Climate Scenarios Redefine Risk Modelling for Financial Institutions

Short-Term Climate Scenarios Redefine Risk Modelling for Financial Institutions

A senior climate risk leader described how banks are shifting toward short-term, granular climate scenarios that better reflect real-world shocks, regulatory expectations and local economic vulnerabilities. The speaker highlighted growing use of sensitivi
  • Climate scenario design shifting to be more credible granular and relevant amid recent macro geopolitical and operational shocks

  • Rise of short term 3 to 5 year scenarios with abrupt shocks integrating physical hazard models and macroeconomic tools

  • Challenge in defining counterfactuals as baselines diverge and NGFS frameworks evolve

  • Ad hoc sensitivity tests like NYC Local Law 97 help assess asset vulnerability compliance costs and strategies

  • Greater local and sector granularity such as Port Arthur TX case showing cascading market and environmental shocks

  • Need for stronger data governance harmonization and cross functional alignment

  • Embedding scenario insights into KPIs underwriting limits finance targets and enterprise risk reports

  • Leveraging business line insights to refine transition risk modeling

  • Regulatory fragmentation requires consistency without duplication while methodology gaps remain

As regulatory expectations intensify across regions, the evolution of climate risk scenario design is entering a more complex and consequential phase. 

At the forefront of this transformation is the recognition that traditional long-horizon, net-zero-aligned scenarios, while essential, often struggle to gain traction amid more immediate macroeconomic, geopolitical, and operational pressures. 

The experience of the past five years - from pandemic-induced oil price collapses to geopolitical shocks and inflation spikes - has fundamentally reshaped the global risk landscape. 

Within this turbulent context, the challenge lies in making climate scenario analysis more credible, granular, and relevant to decision-making today.

One emerging priority is the development of short-term scenarios, typically spanning three to five years. 

These are being increasingly explored to anticipate regulatory shifts toward assessing near-term climate risks. 

Unlike long-dated pathways that assume smooth transitions, short-term narratives often integrate abrupt shocks, such as acute physical climate events and sudden policy reactions. 

The growing ambition in this area is not only about anticipating tipping points but also about operationalizing the integration of physical hazard models with macroeconomic forecasting tools - a complex, but necessary advancement. 

A persistent challenge here is defining appropriate counterfactual scenarios, especially when economic cycles and monetary policy baselines diverge significantly from earlier assumptions. 

With each new iteration of global scenario frameworks, such as those from NGFS, maintaining consistency in counterfactual design remains a difficult balancing act.

In the absence of regulatory clarity, some institutions are instead preparing through ad hoc sensitivity analyses. 

These targeted exercises allow for scenario experimentation that is both pragmatic and locally meaningful. 

An example from the U.S. context illustrates this well: New York City's Local Law 97, which penalizes large buildings for failing to reduce emissions, offers a case study in assessing asset-level vulnerability. 

Through sensitivity tests that compare retrofit investments against growing penalty trajectories, organizations can tangibly assess compliance strategies, operational costs, and long-term financial impacts. 

These analyses are often more persuasive to internal stakeholders than abstract 30-year decarbonization scenarios.

A second key evolution in climate stress testing lies in increasing the geographical and sectoral granularity of scenario narratives. 

Within the U.S. market, localized modeling down to metropolitan statistical areas has provided new depth to impact assessments. 

For example, the coastal city of Port Arthur, Texas, with its heavy reliance on the largest oil refinery in the U.S., demonstrates how local economies can be disproportionately affected by both market and environmental shocks. 

During the COVID-induced oil price crash, refinery shutdowns led to soaring unemployment and a collapse in commercial real estate prices. 

The same area has also suffered from repeated hurricanes, compounding the economic damage. 

Scenarios that account for such repeat acute events - and the second-order effects on infrastructure, insurance availability, and supply chains - reflect the growing expectation from regulators, such as the Federal Reserve, to look beyond direct asset damage and assess ripple effects across economic systems.

Capturing these cascading impacts requires not just better models, but a stronger data and governance foundation. 

Harmonizing data across regions, improving internal data collection processes, and aligning across risk, finance, and business functions remain ongoing hurdles. 

Yet, there is a growing sense that this investment is foundational to advancing the maturity of climate risk management.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Sign up

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.