Expanding and diverging regulation threatens to make financial services compliance increasingly complex and costly. Spruille Braden, Head of Enterprise Resilience at MassMutual, argues that firms can build scalable frameworks by standardizing common controls, measuring genuine risk outcomes and using technology within strong governance and human accountability.
Financial institutions operating
across multiple jurisdictions face an uncomfortable contradiction.
Regulatory expectations continue to
expand, yet adding more compliance processes, assessments and technology does
not automatically create better risk management.
For Spruille Braden, Head of
Enterprise Resilience at MassMutual, addressing that challenge requires
institutions to move away from fragmented compliance structures toward globally
consistent frameworks built around the risks regulation is intended to control.
“I believe the most effective model
is a globally consistent framework with disciplined local execution,” Braden
said.
The starting point should be a single
regulatory inventory, supported by common business process and risk taxonomies
and an enterprise control library.
Each regulatory obligation can then
be connected directly to the relevant risks, processes, controls and evidence.
This allows an institution to
establish a common control baseline rather than repeatedly creating separate
approaches for individual markets.
Jurisdiction-specific requirements
can be added where necessary, while the organization retains an aggregated view
of residual risk.
However, standardization cannot come
at the expense of accountability. Braden argues that clear global and local
ownership must be accompanied by centralized regulatory change governance and
common reporting thresholds.
The approach also challenges one of
the perennial weaknesses of compliance management: confusing completed activity
with effective risk mitigation.
“From my perspective, compliance must
be connected to business outcomes not measured by completed activities alone,”
Braden said.
Training completion, policy
attestations and review volumes can demonstrate that processes have occurred.
They do not necessarily demonstrate that an institution is safer or that the
underlying regulatory objective has been achieved.
Instead, obligations should be mapped
to the risks they are designed to mitigate and the critical services and
processes they support. Firms can then evaluate control effectiveness, residual
risk trends, incidents, customer or market impacts and remediation quality.
Strong challenge and scenario
analysis can further test whether controls remain effective, while escalation
against defined risk appetite can help turn compliance information into
management decisions.
Achieving that consistency becomes
more difficult when regulatory requirements diverge between markets. Braden
favors what he describes as “structured decomposition and deliberate
standardisation.”
Rules can be broken into discrete
obligations and mapped against shared taxonomies and control libraries.
Firms can then identify which
requirements are effectively equivalent, which impose stricter standards and
which are genuinely unique to individual jurisdictions.
“A ‘highest common denominator’
standard can be applied where it is proportionate, while local overlays address
legitimate differences,” Braden said.
That distinction could eliminate
significant duplication. Centers of expertise, reusable evidence, integrated
assurance and common data definitions can all reduce parallel work, while an
enterprise view of regulatory change helps institutions understand the
collective impact of new requirements.
Some differences will inevitably
remain. Where regulatory divergence creates unavoidable costs or risks, Braden
believes the implications should be transparent, risk based and escalated
through the appropriate governance forum rather than absorbed unquestioningly
into additional processes.
Nor does he expect complete
international regulatory harmonization to solve the problem.
“I expect full synchronisation to
remain unlikely because laws, supervisory mandates, market structures and
national priorities differ,” Braden said.
Greater convergence is nevertheless
achievable around outcomes, principles, definitions and data standards.
Operational resilience, cyber incident reporting, third-party and cloud
oversight, AI governance, data and privacy requirements, and core prudential
standards could particularly benefit.
These increasingly represent
cross-border risks. Differing definitions, reporting formats and timelines can
therefore generate substantial compliance costs without necessarily producing
greater protection.