Dr. Arthur Krebbers, Managing Director, Sustainable Finance Advisory at NatWest Commercial & Institutional, explains why physical climate risk is becoming increasingly important to sovereign creditworthiness. He examines the challenges of measuring adaptation, mobilizing private investment and incorporating climate resilience into bond pricing, arguing that preparedness could become a decisive factor in financial risk assessments.
As climate-related disasters become increasingly frequent and
costly, the financial consequences are extending beyond damaged infrastructure
and disrupted economic activity.
For sovereign borrowers, physical climate risk is emerging as
a potentially significant determinant of creditworthiness, fiscal resilience
and access to investment.
According to Dr. Arthur Krebbers, Managing Director,
Sustainable Finance Advisory at NatWest Commercial & Institutional,
investors and lenders are increasingly recognizing that a country's ability to
withstand environmental shocks may be as important as its exposure to those
threats.
"Physical climate risk is becoming an increasingly
relevant component of sovereign and indeed corporate credit assessments,"
he explains, highlighting its potential implications for economic growth,
fiscal balances, infrastructure resilience and debt-servicing capacity.
The growing importance of adaptation could ultimately change
how financial markets assess sovereign risk, allocate capital and distinguish
between countries facing similar environmental threats.
Climate Exposure Alone Cannot Explain Credit Risk
Investors, lenders and credit rating agencies are placing
greater emphasis on climate vulnerability, adaptation preparedness and the
potential fiscal consequences of future disasters.
Improved geospatial information and climate modeling have
strengthened their ability to assess physical risks, but important analytical
weaknesses remain.
One challenge is identifying which assets are most
economically significant to a sovereign borrower or corporation. Another is
quantifying the indirect consequences of climate events as disruption spreads
through economic systems.
Incomplete disclosures concerning local adaptation measures
and their effectiveness further complicate assessments. Corporate borrowers
also face limited visibility into critical supply chain assets.
Krebbers emphasizes that vulnerability cannot be assessed
through physical exposure alone.
"While climate hazard exposure matters, so does
institutional capacity," he says.
Countries with stronger governance arrangements, greater
fiscal flexibility and credible adaptation planning may be better equipped to
manage comparable environmental threats.
For sovereign debt investors, this distinction introduces an
additional dimension to credit analysis.
Two countries facing similar climate hazards may experience
significantly different financial consequences depending on their preparedness
and institutional resilience.
Adaptation Becomes a Financial Stability Concern
Climate adaptation is also moving beyond its traditional
classification as an environmental issue.
Krebbers argues that preparedness for physical climate
impacts is becoming increasingly relevant to financial stability and investment
risk management.
This is particularly important for long-dated, illiquid and
lower-rated investments, where resilience can have a more pronounced influence
on expected returns.
However, determining the financial value of adaptation
remains difficult.
Climate resilience investments often overlap with broader
infrastructure improvements or operational enhancements, making it challenging
to isolate their specific contribution.
Separating adaptation benefits from wider economic and
geopolitical developments presents another obstacle.
Disclosure standards also remain immature.
"Adaptation strategic disclosures remain largely
qualitative," Krebbers observes, noting the absence of a widely adopted
adaptation benchmarking framework equivalent to the Task Force on
Climate-related Financial Disclosures approach to climate risk reporting.
Consequently, although adaptation is becoming more
influential in investment decisions, the methodologies required to measure its
effectiveness remain under development.
Financing Resilience Requires Clear Economic Benefits
The growing financial importance of adaptation raises another
fundamental question: who should finance it?
Governments face increasing fiscal pressures from
climate-related damage while simultaneously needing substantial investment in
protective infrastructure and resilience.
Krebbers identifies the distribution of economic benefits as
a central consideration when structuring adaptation finance.
"The key challenge is identifying who benefits from
resilience investments and structuring financing accordingly," he
explains.
Many adaptation and nature-based infrastructure projects
generate benefits across society rather than producing clearly identifiable
commercial returns.
This helps explain why governments and public institutions
continue to play a central financing role.
Private capital becomes easier to attract when resilience
investments deliver measurable financial advantages.
These might include compliance with regulatory or building
standards, revenue from carbon credits, lower insurance costs, reduced
operational disruption or improvements in asset values.
Where such benefits can be demonstrated, financing structures
can combine public investment with private participation and appropriate
risk-sharing arrangements.
The objective is to mobilize additional commercial capital
without overlooking the wider societal benefits that may not generate direct
investment returns.
For banks and institutional investors, this creates
opportunities to develop financing arrangements that connect measurable
resilience outcomes with appropriate risk and return characteristics.
Sovereign Bond Markets Could Reprice Climate Preparedness
Looking ahead 10 to 15 years, Krebbers expects sovereign bond
markets to become increasingly capable of distinguishing between countries
according to their climate resilience.
However, he anticipates gradual rather than sudden changes.
"Yes, although the process is likely to be gradual
rather than sudden," he says.
Improved climate information, disclosure standards and
adaptation benchmarks should allow investors to evaluate preparedness alongside
physical exposure.