BNP Paribas has completed the integration of climate risk into its IFRS 9 provisioning framework, eliminating the need for climate overlays. Marc Irubetagoyena explains how the bank is addressing data limitations, incorporating geopolitical uncertainty and preparing to extend its credit risk methodologies to nature and biodiversity risks.
Climate risk is moving from
supplementary adjustments into the core of credit provisioning, with BNP
Paribas completing a significant transformation of its expected credit loss
(ECL) methodologies that could offer a blueprint for other financial institutions.
Marc Irubetagoyena, Head of Modelling
& Simulating at BNP Paribas, explains that the bank has fully integrated
material climate risk factors into its IFRS 9 framework, replacing temporary
overlays with quantitative modeling approaches.
The development marks an important
shift in how environmental risks influence credit assessments and financial
reporting.
"BNP Paribas identified both
transition and physical climate risk factors as material risks at an early
stage within its risk identification framework," Irubetagoyena says.
Since the end of 2024, these factors
have been reflected through climate-related adjustments to credit ratings and
loss given default parameters, alongside forward-looking impacts incorporated
into credit risk calculations.
Although most material climate risks
were directly modeled by year-end 2024, physical risks affecting corporate
exposures initially required additional overlays.
"The full delivery of BNP
Paribas' IFRS 9 climate modelling framework was completed by year-end 2025,
allowing the cancellation of climate overlays and the full integration of
climate factors into provisioning methodologies," Irubetagoyena explains.
However, achieving greater
sophistication in environmental provisioning does not eliminate the practical
challenges associated with reliable risk quantification.
Data availability remains the most
significant obstacle, particularly when developing climate-enhanced
macroeconomic scenarios and forward-looking impact models.
Financial institutions require
detailed information about client emissions, transition plans, building
locations and physical asset characteristics to assess how environmental
developments could affect creditworthiness.
Irubetagoyena emphasizes that
modeling horizons must also reflect the duration of underlying credit
portfolios, concentrating on material environmental risks within relevant
timeframes.
These challenges become more complex
when climate exposures interact with geopolitical uncertainty.
Energy markets, supply chains and
broader economic conditions provide common transmission channels through which
geopolitical and environmental shocks can influence credit risk.
"Climate and geopolitical risks
often affect similar transmission channels, particularly through energy
markets, supply chains, and broader economic activity," he says.
Nevertheless, the availability of
information differs considerably between the two risk categories.
At BNP Paribas, climate-related
impacts are assessed at individual client level, while forward-looking
geopolitical effects are evaluated across sectors and geographic regions.
Their interactions are incorporated
into scenario design, allowing macroeconomic analysis to reflect both
dimensions consistently.
Looking beyond climate change,
Irubetagoyena expects nature and biodiversity risks to become increasingly
important considerations for financial institutions.
However, limited data, localized
environmental exposures and difficulties constructing meaningful scenarios
complicate their incorporation into credit provisioning.
"The most promising approach is
to build on the foundations already established for climate risk
management," he explains.