Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Articles

Article October 23, 2026

Banks Warn Flawed Hedge Accounting Rules Threaten Balance Sheet Efficiency

Banks Warn Flawed Hedge Accounting Rules Threaten Balance Sheet Efficiency

A global bank's senior IRRBB executive warns that proposed risk mitigation accounting reforms could restrict hedging flexibility and undermine balance sheet efficiency. Advocating an alternative "held for hedging" approach, he urges banks to challenge accounting constraints that complicate structural hedging, increase costs and create unnecessary liquidity and capital trade-offs.



  • Global bank executive challenges proposed IASB risk mitigation accounting reforms
  • Internal testing reveals significant difficulties implementing the RMA framework
  • Existing hedge accounting rules can distort structural interest rate risk management
  • Proposed "held for hedging" model would align accounting with business strategy
  • Greater derivative flexibility could improve liquidity and capital efficiency
  • Fair value disclosures would remain essential for investor transparency
  • Prudential regulators should oversee excessive risk rather than accounting rules
  • Banks urged to contribute evidence before the November consultation deadline

A senior interest rate risk executive at a global bank has urged banks to challenge proposed international hedge accounting reforms that risk increasing costs, restricting balance sheet optimization and creating unnecessary capital volatility.

 

The global head of interest rate risk in the banking book (IRRBB) argued that the International Accounting Standards Board's (IASB) proposed risk mitigation accounting (RMA) framework failed to reflect how major financial institutions actually manage structural hedges.

 

Speaking at CeFPro's 2026 Balance Sheet Management Europe conference he called on banks to participate in the consultation process and support alternative approaches that would align accounting treatment more closely with established risk management practices.

"If we have better rules, they drive better outcomes," he said, arguing that existing requirements imposed constraints rooted in outdated assumptions about derivatives.

The executive explained that banks typically manage structural interest rate exposures through combinations of fixed-rate loans, securities and derivatives, each carrying different liquidity, capital and accounting implications.

Fixed-rate lending provides natural hedging opportunities, but customer demand frequently moves against banks' preferred hedging strategies. Securities can stabilize earnings, although holding them for that purpose may restrict liquidity or introduce capital volatility.

Derivatives offer greater flexibility but create accounting complications because they are generally measured at fair value through profit and loss unless they qualify for hedge accounting.

The executive argued that this treatment created an artificial distinction between economically equivalent interest rate positions.

He illustrated the problem by comparing a fixed-rate bond funded through floating-rate liabilities with a derivative receiving fixed interest and paying floating interest.

Although both produce similar interest rate exposures, their accounting treatment can differ substantially.

"It's not about the product, it's about the risk," he said.

The IASB's RMA proposals seek to address this disconnect by improving alignment between accounting and risk management while strengthening external disclosures.

However, the executive said extensive internal testing at his institution had revealed fundamental implementation difficulties.

"We cannot make RMA work," he said, while emphasizing support for the standard setter's underlying objectives.

One particular obstacle involved the treatment of internal funding arrangements between banking and trading books.

The executive explained that banking book interest rate exposures could include substantial internal lending that disappears from consolidated accounting measures, creating discrepancies between accounting calculations and the risks treasury actually manages.

He also questioned restrictions affecting equity and the use of derivatives when hedging exposures.

As an alternative, his institution was advocating a business model approach known as "held for hedging."

Under this proposal, derivatives designated for structural banking book risk management would receive accounting treatment reflecting their economic purpose, provided the underlying strategy was subject to appropriate governance.

The executive emphasized that the approach would not eliminate transparency requirements.

Fair values would continue to be disclosed, allowing investors to assess interest rate exposures and potential vulnerabilities.

He argued that prudential supervisors, rather than accounting standard setters, should remain responsible for controlling excessive interest rate risk.

The potential advantages extend beyond simplifying complex and expensive hedge accounting processes.

Greater flexibility to use derivatives could reduce banks' dependence on securities held to collect contractual cash flows, improving their ability to monetize liquidity portfolios during stress.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Sign up

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.