Financial institutions must move beyond treating climate change and biodiversity loss as separate risks, warns Stéphane Dees of Banque de France. As ecosystem degradation creates increasingly complex financial exposures, banks face significant methodological challenges in integrating nature risk into existing frameworks. Better geospatial analysis, scenario modeling and supply chain mapping will be essential.
Financial institutions risk
underestimating their exposure to environmental threats unless they recognize
that climate change, biodiversity loss and ecosystem degradation are
increasingly interconnected drivers of financial instability.
Stéphane Dees, Head of the Climate
Finance Unit at Banque de France, argues that banks must move toward integrated
environmental risk management rather than developing separate frameworks that
fail to capture the relationships between climate and nature.
The most immediate opportunities for
integration exist in sectors where economic activity depends heavily on
environmental conditions, particularly agriculture, forestry and real estate.
"The most immediate practical
overlap lies in land-use sectors such as agriculture, forestry, and real
estate, where climate adaptation and ecosystem health are directly
intertwined," Dees explains.
Financial institutions can already
incorporate nature-related indicators into existing climate risk assessments,
particularly when evaluating physical hazards such as droughts and floods.
Water stress analysis, for example,
can provide valuable information about both climate vulnerability and ecosystem
dependencies, allowing banks to identify potential exposures without
constructing entirely new risk management systems.
However, Dees cautions against simply
adapting climate methodologies to nature-related risks.
"Rather than forcing nature risk
into a single carbon-equivalent metric, institutions should adopt a spatial and
location-specific approach that focuses on dependencies and impacts," he
says.
Sector heatmaps and geospatial tools
such as ENCORE offer practical starting points, helping institutions identify
localized concentrations of vulnerability before attempting more sophisticated
financial valuations.
Nevertheless, the transition from
identifying individual exposures to understanding systemic financial
consequences remains a significant obstacle.
Dees identifies methodology, rather
than simply insufficient data or governance weaknesses, as the central
challenge facing regulators and financial institutions.
"The primary challenge is
methodological, particularly in relation to macro-financial transmission
modelling," he explains.
Unlike many climate risk assessments,
nature-related exposures are highly localized, frequently nonlinear and
potentially characterized by extreme tail risks.
Consequently, translating ecosystem
degradation into broader economic shocks and meaningful financial stability
indicators remains difficult for central banks and supervisors.
These limitations become particularly
important when considering how environmental disruptions might spread across
economic sectors and financial institutions.
Looking ahead five years, Dees
envisages a more comprehensive approach that combines climate transition
pathways, ecosystem service degradation and double materiality within unified
macro-financial scenarios.
Such frameworks would require
institutions to develop stronger capabilities in geospatial asset-location
tracking, supply chain exposure mapping and reporting aligned with the
Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures.
Central banks and supervisory
organizations, including the Network for Greening the Financial System, are
already exploring how nature-related risks can be incorporated into scenario
analysis.