Mira Lamriben, Climate Risk Expert at the European Banking Authority, explains why environmental scenario analysis must move beyond regulatory compliance to influence banking strategy. She examines supervisory expectations, methodological challenges, the integration of climate risks into capital and liquidity planning, and the growing importance of biodiversity and other environmental threats.
European banks face growing expectations to demonstrate that
environmental scenario analysis delivers meaningful insights into financial
vulnerabilities and influences management decisions, rather than simply
satisfying regulatory requirements.
As climate risk methodologies mature, supervisors are
increasingly concerned with how institutions interpret scenario results,
incorporate findings into existing risk management frameworks and use those
insights to challenge their business models.
According to Mira Lamriben, Climate Risk Expert at the
European Banking Authority (EBA), the distinction between conducting
environmental scenario analysis and making effective use of its findings is
becoming increasingly important.
"One of the main messages from the EBA is that
environmental scenario analysis should not be treated as a standalone modelling
or compliance exercise," she explains.
Instead, institutions need coherent, forward-looking
frameworks connecting environmental risk drivers to established financial risk
categories, balance sheet exposures and strategic decision-making.
Lamriben believes supervisory attention will increasingly
concentrate on the quality and practical application of scenario analysis
rather than the mere completion of an exercise.
Stress Testing Is Not the Same as Resilience Analysis
A fundamental challenge for banks is understanding the
different purposes of environmental stress testing and longer-term resilience
analysis.
While closely related, the two approaches address distinct
questions about an institution's vulnerability to environmental developments.
Stress testing should examine shorter-term consequences for
financial risks, capital adequacy and liquidity. Resilience analysis,
meanwhile, should assess whether a bank's business model and strategy remain
sustainable under different environmental pathways over longer periods.
This distinction matters because an institution might
demonstrate an ability to absorb near-term financial shocks without necessarily
establishing that its underlying business strategy remains viable as
environmental conditions change.
Lamriben argues that supervisors will increasingly expect
institutions to demonstrate how their analysis informs management responses.
"Ultimately, supervisors will increasingly be interested
in the ‘so what?’ question: what has the institution learned from the analysis,
and how has that insight changed risk management or strategic decisions."
The implication is that technically sophisticated models will
have limited value if their findings remain disconnected from business
decisions.
Methodological Complexity Must Serve a Purpose
Banks continue to encounter substantial challenges in
developing environmental risk models, particularly where reliable data and
established methodologies remain unavailable.
However, Lamriben cautions against treating methodological
sophistication as an objective in itself.
"The EBA expects proportionality rather than
sophistication for its own sake," she says.
Institutions can employ proxies, qualitative assessments and
expert judgment where necessary, provided they remain transparent about
methodological weaknesses and demonstrate credible plans for improvement.
This approach recognizes that environmental risk analysis
remains an evolving discipline and that institutions possess differing levels
of capability.
The critical requirement is not to eliminate uncertainty
before conducting meaningful analysis, but to acknowledge limitations and
strengthen the reliability of assessments over time.
For banks, this places particular importance on governance
arrangements that can distinguish between genuinely informative results and
conclusions constrained by incomplete data or immature modelling techniques.
Connecting Climate Scenarios to Banking Decisions
Perhaps the clearest indication of maturity is whether
scenario analysis produces identifiable changes in risk management or business
strategy.
Lamriben argues that institutions should establish a
demonstrable connection between analytical findings and subsequent management
action.
"The key question is: what changed because of the
analysis?" she says.
Material vulnerabilities identified through environmental
scenarios could influence risk appetite, concentration limits, credit policies,
underwriting standards and lending decisions.
They could also affect pricing, collateral requirements,
portfolio steering and engagement with customers operating in environmentally
vulnerable sectors.
For example, identifying a concentration of exposures
susceptible to a particular environmental pathway could prompt a bank to
reconsider its sectoral limits or adjust its approach to new lending.
Similarly, scenario findings might identify clients requiring
greater engagement or business activities where additional risk mitigation is
necessary.
"So the test of maturity is whether we can trace a
scenario result through to a risk-management or strategic response,"
Lamriben explains.
This emphasis on traceability represents an important shift
from assessing analytical capability toward evaluating its practical
contribution to financial risk management.
From Periodic Exercises to Strategic Planning
Over the next three to five years, Lamriben expects
environmental scenario analysis to become increasingly embedded within banks'
normal strategic planning processes.
Rather than maintaining separate environmental risk
assessments, institutions should connect their analysis with the Internal
Capital Adequacy Assessment Process (ICAAP), Internal Liquidity Adequacy
Assessment Process (ILAAP), risk appetite frameworks, transition planning and
budgeting.
Portfolio steering and broader strategic planning should also
incorporate environmental scenario findings.
Lamriben anticipates a shift away from periodic exercises
that produce static results toward more dynamic assessments capable of testing
alternative strategic choices.