Senior banking risk executives warn that geopolitical uncertainty is rendering traditional stress testing assumptions increasingly unreliable. They advocate broader scenario analysis, stronger governance, reverse stress testing and faster management responses, emphasizing that financial institutions must prioritize preparedness over prediction while incorporating cyber threats, AI risks and complex geopolitical transmission channels.
Banks must abandon the illusion that
geopolitical crises can be reliably predicted and instead develop stress
testing frameworks capable of identifying unexpected vulnerabilities and
supporting rapid management intervention, senior financial risk executives have
warned.
Speaking during a panel discussion at
CeFPro's recent Balance Sheet Management Europe conference, a head of stress
testing at a European public-sector investment bank argued that financial
institutions needed to fundamentally reconsider the purpose of scenario
analysis.
"Nowadays, things are changing
very quickly," he said, describing a necessary shift "from
predictability to preparedness."
That transition requires institutions
to understand portfolio vulnerabilities, identify transmission channels and
prepare management responses before geopolitical events threaten financial
stability.
The discussion highlighted how
conventional macroeconomic stress testing has become increasingly inadequate
for capturing risks arising from military conflict, sanctions, cyberattacks and
rapidly changing international relationships.
A head of balance sheet risk
management at a European banking group operating across Central and Eastern
Europe argued that recent geopolitical developments demonstrated the
limitations of confidence in conventional forecasting.
He said institutions needed to
acknowledge uncertainty and develop broader collections of scenarios, including
events previously considered highly improbable.
"What all the geopolitics told
me is to be more humble, to be with my ideas, to be with my probabilities,
because probably the reality will be different," he explained.
The executive advocated combining
narrative-based scenarios with more conservative general stress tests capable
of capturing vulnerabilities that specific geopolitical assumptions might
overlook.
A head of climate risk scenario
design at a global banking institution similarly emphasized the importance of
challenging established assumptions about plausible geopolitical developments.
He argued that the pandemic and
Russia's invasion of Ukraine demonstrated why institutions should consider
extreme scenarios rather than dismiss them because of historically low
probabilities.
Scenario development should also
incorporate sector-specific consequences, recognizing that geopolitical
disruption can damage some industries while creating opportunities for others.
The public-sector investment bank's
stress testing head said narrative-based analysis was particularly valuable
because it made complex risks understandable to senior management.
He argued that internal stress tests,
regulatory exercises and reverse stress testing served complementary purposes
and should operate within a coherent framework.
Internal testing was especially
important for identifying institution-specific vulnerabilities and informing
capital planning and risk appetite decisions.
Reverse stress testing, meanwhile,
could reveal overlooked transmission channels and exposures that conventional
scenarios failed to capture.
The global bank's scenario design
executive emphasized that developing detailed narratives could itself become an
important risk identification exercise.
By involving sector specialists and
challenging assumptions, institutions could build scenario libraries that
supported contingency planning when previously hypothetical threats began to
materialize.
The discussion also examined how
geopolitical stress testing should influence practical balance sheet decisions.
The European banking group's balance
sheet risk management head explained that his institution assessed whether
existing general stress tests adequately captured emerging geopolitical
exposures across its different markets.
Where they did not, additional stress
assumptions, revised limits or larger liquidity buffers could be introduced.
Adverse scenarios were also
incorporated into budgeting, capital planning and funding assessments, with
recovery measures developed where existing resources appeared insufficient.
However, participants acknowledged
the difficulties of applying consistent scenarios across international banking
groups.
Different countries, legal entities
and portfolios could experience sharply contrasting outcomes from identical
geopolitical developments.