Skip to content

Content Library

Back to Articles

Article December 31, 2025

The Divergence Conundrum - How AI’s Redefining of Financial Risk Widens Governance Gaps

The Divergence Conundrum - How AI’s Redefining of Financial Risk Widens Governance Gaps

Christopher Smigielski, Risk Model & Director, Arvest Bank GroupLinkedIn profile for Christopher Smigielski

Financial institutions are rapidly rethinking AI governance as machine learning and Generative AI push beyond traditional model risk frameworks. Model Risk expert Chris Smigielski outlines how Arvest Bank broadens oversight to include non-traditional AI t
  • AI risk management must go beyond rigid definitions to capture all relevant risks

  • Arvest Bank adapts SR 11 7 to oversee AI and non traditional tools like fraud monitoring and AML systems

  • AI Center of Excellence manages inventory assessment and monitoring for AI tools outside model risk scope

  • Performance monitoring for GenAI is complex and needs automated scalable solutions

  • Governance prioritizes use case specific risk levels and human oversight needs

  • Vendor transparency on fairness and bias is essential and lack of proof is flagged

  • Regulation is fragmented but proactive principle based governance is pursued

  • AI literacy with mandatory employee training ensures safe and effective adoption

  • Governance must balance innovation with oversight and accountability

Our technological landscape is evolving so rapidly that conversations about artificial intelligence (AI) risk management often struggle to keep up. We get stuck in definitions - what is a model, what is AI, and where do we draw the line? 

As a panellist at CeFPro’s Advanced Model Risk 2025 conference this year, discussing risk practices with colleagues from institutions like Morgan Stanley and Flagstar Bank, I found myself returning to a more pragmatic stance. 

The reality is, regardless of labels or regulatory clarity, AI is here, it's expanding fast, and financial institutions must decide how to govern it effectively – and they need to decide now.

At Arvest Bank, like many others, we began our AI risk journey anchored in SR 11-7. It’s a solid, principles-based framework, and when we first wrote our model risk management policy, SR 11-7 was our north star. 

But AI, especially machine learning and now Generative AI (GenAI), has pushed us beyond the comfortable boundaries of traditional model risk management.

We quickly realized that if we limited ourselves to the strict definition of a "model," we’d leave significant risks unmanaged - not because they didn’t exist, but because they didn’t fit neatly into outdated categories.

Our model inventory evolved organically. It wasn’t just predictive models anymore; we started including tools like fraud monitoring systems and AML frameworks. 

These aren’t conventional models - they’re often rules-based - but they are critical to the bank’s operations and, therefore, require oversight. 

The same logic applies to AI. Not every AI implementation should be forced into a model risk framework but ignoring them is not an option either.

This is why we created an AI Center of Excellence at Arvest. If something contains AI but doesn’t meet our definition of a model, it still lands within this governance structure. 

It’s a flexible, risk-based framework informed by SR 11-7 but adapted for the nuances of AI. It ensures that AI tools are identified, inventoried, assessed for risk, and monitored over their lifecycle - even if they aren’t formally validated like traditional models. 

I’d rather have a conversation with regulators about which framework is appropriate than explain why we ignored something entirely.

One of the biggest challenges I highlighted during the panel is performance monitoring. 

With traditional models, you know the drill - annual reviews, recalculations, outcome analysis. But how do you apply that discipline to AI tools, especially GenAI applications where outputs can vary day-to-day? 

The answer isn’t straightforward, and it’s clear we can’t tackle this manually, since AI scales across institutions. 

I’ve been actively engaging vendors to explore automated solutions, because if we have a manageable number of AI instances today, that number will likely multiply exponentially in the coming years. Without automation, we risk being overwhelmed.

Another critical point from our discussion was the shift from focusing solely on algorithms to focusing on use cases. 

AI isn’t inherently risky; it’s how you use it that matters. A GenAI tool summarizing tax documents for loan applications is a very different risk profile than one involved in credit decisioning.

For us, governance starts with understanding that use case, identifying where human oversight is required, and ensuring that risks like fairness, bias, and explainability are addressed - especially in areas like credit where regulatory scrutiny is intense.

One example I shared was dealing with vendors who provide machine learning credit models. 

When we asked for documentation on fairness and bias testing, we were told, ‘trust us, we don’t discriminate’. That’s not good enough. Even without prescriptive regulation, we know these are areas where AI can introduce unintended harm, so we flagged it and demanded better transparency. 

It’s also driven deeper collaboration across departments - model risk, fair lending, compliance, data science. AI governance isn’t a siloed responsibility anymore; it’s a company-wide effort.

Events you may be interested in

View all of our upcoming events

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Sign up

Connect Plus

Unlock more with Connect Plus membership

This content is available to Connect Plus members.